LOST - Wednesday 11/9/05 {Spoilers for this ep and previous eps ONLY!}

[Hand of Evil]

I saw Cindy's disappearance as being just a plot device to put Anna on edge...which is why she shot the first person she saw (who could have just as easily been Cindy).

Then again, could have been a mole...

 

[Mazlo]

I think that Cindy is an Other. The other survivors didn't have the plane manifest so they couldn't take a census and discover who had infiltrated the camp (Remember Ethan in S1). But why are the Others trying to infiltrate the survivor camps? Why are they attacking them? Hmm.

 

[RedShirtNo5]

"This week, one of the survivors will be lost... forever."

Shannon could live, since Cindy might fulfil the promo. But I agree it is more interesting for Shannon to die and Cindy to be an Other.

-RedShirtNo5

 

[satori01]

I did not catch any hpye leading up to this episode, so being unaware that someone was supposed to be capped, made the ending unexpected.

I personaly dislike Shannon too, but in some ways think it is a shame if they kill her off. Lets face it in a circumstance like being stranded with a group of strangers, someone will have a personality that bugs the hell out of you.

Her background flashbacks made her more sympathetic, and more rounded. Girl has issues, no doubt about that, but she was to put in in technical jargon "screwed royally" by her step mother.

Flashbacks also revealed Boone for what he has always been, a lapdog, lackey, and follower.
Anyone else think next episode is going to start with Jack having to make a decision whom to save? Very intresting if the whole
Carlyle/Rutherford family is so to speak "Voted off the Island".

 

[shaylon]

Was that Jack walking past the doctors when they are in the hospital.

From msnbc.com story

Though we saw Shannon was close to her father, the details of his death remain fuzzy, and now she's not around to clarify them. Astute viewers remember that Adam Rutherford was not only her dad but the man Jack let die so he could save his future fiancée, Sarah. Shannon's death leaves unanswered whether she knew Dr. Jack made that fateful choice.

Dun Dun DUUNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN!!

Later,
Shay

 

[WizarDru]

Can anyone tell me what Walt told Shannon when he appeared to her? I couldn't make out a bloody thing!

"They're coming... and they're close."

 

[Flexor the Mighty!]

From msnbc.com story

Though we saw Shannon was close to her father, the details of his death remain fuzzy, and now she's not around to clarify them. Astute viewers remember that Adam Rutherford was not only her dad but the man Jack let die so he could save his future fiancée, Sarah. Shannon's death leaves unanswered whether she knew Dr. Jack made that fateful choice.

Dun Dun DUUNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN!!

Later,
Shay

Damn how did I miss that?

Great episode. I really liked seeing Boone again and Shannon's backstory. Hopefully Sayed shoots Anna. I disliked her character from the start and she hasn't made me like her any more since.

 

[fett527]

Damn how did I miss that?

Great episode. I really liked seeing Boone again and Shannon's backstory. Hopefully Sayed shoots Anna. I disliked her character from the start and she hasn't made me like her any more since.

I'm not sure since we've talked about it at length in previous threads and I've already restated it in a post earlier in this thread.

 

[Flexor the Mighty!]

I'm not sure since we've talked about it at length in previous threads and I've already restated it in a post earlier in this thread.

I don't read the Lost threads too close. And you guys knew that Shannon's father was the guy who died in that accident before this week?

 

[fett527]

Comments and SPOILERS! Could someone please edit the thread title?

This has been talked about and I always expect there to be spoilers when any episode thread is started. What I'm afraid of is people talking about future episode spoilers if we lable as such. I'll try to label it clearly.