Hahaha, y'know, going down the path of religious rhetoric was NOT what I assumed would be the problem in this thread, when two girls confessed a love for D&D. I was thinking more "creepy stalkerish" and less "angry religionist"
First, addressing the thread topic, you don't need to give up D&D to be dead sexy. The membership of these boards is proof enough of that. I'm sexy, Teflon Billy is sexy, heck, even Eric Noah himself has been known to have The Pimp Juice. I also heard we had Derek Zoolander and Carrot Top and Vin Disel on these boards.... okay, maybe Carrot Top is not the best example, but...
If your love of D&D is the kind of obsessive, all-consuming love that twists your reality, though, giving it up and persuing self-betterment is a GOOD idea. Balance, moderation, being a well-adjusted human being, is always very important, not just for scoring the ladies, but also for just being a healthy, confident person. And 90% of sexiness is being that healthy, confident person, anyway (the other 10% is mostly water). If it takes breaking down D&D to make you accept reality, well, it's a worthy sacrifice.
Second:
(This is where I get screwed over because there aren't too many Christian gamer guys around here... blehhhh. No wonder I'm 19 and have never had a boyfriend. )
and
Wow, that describes me almost perfectly, except that I am 18
If it strikes your fancy, move out to someplace bigger or just different when you can. Christian gamer guys (or at least gamer guys who respect the Christian values for dating) aren't really that rare; most of my guy friends, like me, fit this mode okay. Go to a bigish-city college, or just find a job and move there if continuing education ain't your thing. I know nothing about where you gals are from, but I know of at least half a dozen nice, single Christian gamers ages 20-24, and that's without even *trying*, here.
Either way, the more people there are, the more likely you'll be able to find someone who meshes with what you're looking for, ya?
And if you ever find yourselves in Madison, maybe you can come to one of those sexy parties I throw.