tarchon said:I didn't start the thread to defend his conclusions, just report my recollections as requested by Mark CMG.
Fair enough. It helps that I wasn't so much asking you to defend him as offering some questioning tidbits for consideration.
I highly recommend http://www.godecookery.com/
We picked up a copy of "A Book of Gode Cookery" only last week (at Pennsic). One of the major assets of this book is that it shows you that what counts as a "recipe" has undergone a major change over time. The number one difference - an almost complete lack of standard measures. No cups, pounds, or ounces. Everything is "some" or "enough"...