Andor
First Post
Actually I believe he is correct. For starters, you only get a proficieny bonus from a weapon on powers with the weapon keyword (and you only get bonus damage from feats and the like for these powers too). Similarly you can only use Implement Mastery with powers that have the implement keyword. I guess the Holy Avenger and Pact Blade were written at a slightly different time or by someone different or edited less, hence they explicitly state the case.
Ahh. I see what you're talking about, on page 275 (and only on page 275) it mentions that proficiency bonuses require the Weapon keyword.
I still see nothing about the feats, or the unnamed kensai and Fighter weapon talent bonuses however.
Frankly I suspect that was the intent, however I take nothing for granted. 4e has got an awful lot of seams showing where development stopped on the way to the printer and it's impossible for me to divine internal game logic in a system that so utterly compromises itself with meta-game concerns.
I might have been a little vitrolic in my last post but good lord does it cheese me off when someone tries that playground "I'll tell you what's right and then jam my fingers in my ears nyah, nyah, nyah" crap.