The High Aldwin
But it isn't just opposite sides, it is also corners, which the red circles show the lines crossing corners of the target's space.The problem with 3 is that the lines are not crossing opposite sides of the target. Opposite sides mean parallel sides.
Now, perhaps you believe it means "opposite corners" (together), such as in this diagram:
In which case I would imagine your interpretation would only allow Y, but not the two ?s to be flanking?
To be clear, I don't think there is anything wrong with that interpretation, just not one I agree with.
But, this is why I want all five votes. With those 4 options, by default one of them should be a majority. If we end up with two tied, we can revote with only those two options and give a majority ruling then.