LordEntrails
Hero
I specifically suggested filtering on number of replies.
Merely filtering away threads with no replies (only the auto post) would go a long way.
The huge advantage is if you or I want to make a "comment", it would instantly rise to the top.
The reason people aren't commenting isn't because they're laze or ungrateful, it's because nobody will ever see their comment if the rest of us must 1) visit DMs Guild 2) happen upon the exact same product page.
Besides, DMs Guide isn't interested. For one thing, they don't want the hassle of a discussion board (which needs moderation etc).
My reply about nobody commenting was not about the DMsG comments, but the fact that the posts here on ENWorld about products get no replies or comments. Look at the latest DMsG product post htat was created on Dec 20th (Homeward Bound), it has ZERO replies and only 158 views.
So, my point is simply, why create threads here on ENWorld if no one is going to use them anyway?