helium3
First Post
Not in my experience. That's not to say there aren't disagreements, though the disagreements are usually IC. And I've seen them resolved more often than not.
Fair enough. Sounds like I need a Caller in my RL group, though. So yeah, I'll ditch the Caller thing for the time being.
Adopting the bump day concept seems like a good idea though. It'll be whatever day I open the IC thread on.
Q: What do you want to rule about "table talk"?
I've found it handy to allow Players to discuss and help eachother - not to kibbitz 'bad' moves - but remind eachother about powers or bonuses or story tidbits that they may have forgotten. It's especially helpful when there might be long periods between posts.
Because IC threads are wonderfully narrative in a way that few of my face-to-face games have been, "table talk" in the OOC thread doesn't detract in the same way as it does from face-to-face games.
I don't have a problem with table talk, honestly. From my experience the game requires team tactics that most groups don't currently posses. Being able to talk about that sorta thing is pretty critical to figuring it out, I'd reckon.
That being said, the sort of table talk I don't want to see is the over-bearing "your character should have done X and I'm going to imply that you're stupid for not doing it" sorta stuff. Basically, have some social grace and be respectful.
How am I going to handle a player that acts like that? Hopefully I won't ever have to deal with it.

Cool note for the shiny new forums... you can use hot-keys to place tags... ctrl-I makes italic tags, ctrl-b makes bold tags. Very handy.
That's very cool!!