Origins of the "New" Races

I have the same issues in mind. If you don't have anything further to comment on my reservations, I think it's a dead horse.

Hang on. Do you disagree with the solutions I proposed to your reservations?

Eladrin jails = 3 foot wide corridors
Walls = more than 25 feet
Etc.


Well, some of the crossing points on the Mississippi are 25 feet wide.

And, do they use ferries at that point? And, really? 25 feet? For the Mississippi river? You cannot even get a decent sized boat down a canal that narrow. We're talking about the width of a single lane street. Canoes have trouble passing each other in that little space. Ok, that's an exageration, but, you get the point.

If the river is only 20-25 feet across, I'm betting they use a bridge. Or, considering your river is only about 8 paces across, it's likely a ford.

Again, I ask, what are the massive world shattering consequences of allowing a 1/5 minutes line of sight only teleport with a range of less than ten paces?
 

log in or register to remove this ad

The point remains that this is the same thing we've always done, that's always been at the heart of fantasy - imagining how the fantastic impacts our perception of a normal world. How does the fantastic nature of Elves affect their communities? They live high up in the trees, for example. How do orcs and goblins build communities given their traits? It's all the same exercise and is entirely core to the idea of fantasy gaming.

Asking the question - how would this trait affect the world, communities, etc? - is a perfectly valid question. But I don't think your reason for asking the question was as valid.

If the question is due to genuine difficulty in conceptualizing something and looking for help to do so, its been answered, in spades. Solutions mundane and magical, basic and complex have been offered, most requiring nothing more than things that already existed. Many of these issues were tackled before with other fantastic situations. How do you imprison a wizard? How do you imprison a master thief? Is a stockade, a hood or a metal mask, all real things that have seen real use in law enforcement, unreasonable measures?

And why couldn't it be a source of adventure when an eladrin murderer teleports his way out of a podunk village's jail that wasn't prepared for fey step and escapes, after inserting a PC appropriate adventure hook on the way out of town?

Maybe an Eladrin community doesn't have ladders up to their guard towers, that would be cool, a nice detail that would help make the community interesting and unique. Maybe their tavern entertainment involves teleporting games. Maybe the other races refuse to allow them on the Blood Bowl pitch.

Either you are asking because you are genuinely interested in the discussion, which you don't seem to be, you are simply dismissive of everything; or you are asking because you want to rail against some other perceived injustice of the new edition and don't care a whit what any other poster has to say about the "problem".
 
Last edited:


Yup. Look it up.

The only thing I could find was on Wiki where the only point where the Mississippi is that narrow is at the head waters. And it has a pedestrian ford. Which makes sense since they ship up and down the river all the time. So, if my Eladrin wants to trek about 3000 miles just so he can teleport across the Mississippi, I fail to see how that is an campaign shaking thing.

So, again, what specific campaign shattering consequences are there of allowing an extremely short range, line of sight only teleport every 5 minutes?

((This is weird, my Firefox does not recognize the word teleport. Bizarre.))
 

Either you are asking because you are genuinely interested in the discussion, which you don't seem to be, you are simply dismissive of everything; or you are asking because you want to rail against some other perceived injustice of the new edition and don't care a whit what any other poster has to say about the "problem".

Please don't ascribe motives to other users. In particular, don't accuse them of trolling or otherwise debating in bad faith. 'cause it's hella rude if you're wrong and quite disruptive even if you're right.
Also, keep in mind that nobody's forcing you to reply to posts you dislike; simply ignoring them is always an option.
 

Remove ads

Top