• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

D&D 5E Out of the Abyss OOC

Something I regularly forget about 5e is that readied actions go as a Reaction. See PHB 193. They don't take up the Action or Bonus Action slot, they take up your Reaction. Maybe you lot have no difficulty remembering that, but I do (3.x stuck in my pea brain). Then again, maybe someone reading this will have an a-ha moment and realize they can do more this round as a result.

Huh? The way I read it is that the Ready action costs your normal action so that you can use it as a reaction later in the round. It'll still cost you your normal action, plus your normal Reaction when the trigger returns true. Maybe you said the same thing and I'm just too tired to process it right. I think I'll go kick in a door and go to bed. :)


-IG
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Nice Journal CB (wish there was a more direct way of commenting!), I had been wondering if you'd tone down some of the torture and slavery aspects for the youngsters! I was aware of the possibility of burning through the rope bridges and webbing but was holding that as a last resort for if the situation gets absolutely dire:-)

Hopefully our group will manage to stop Asha (and Ilvara?) from escaping..
 



Huh? The way I read it is that the Ready action costs your normal action so that you can use it as a reaction later in the round. It'll still cost you your normal action, plus your normal Reaction when the trigger returns true. Maybe you said the same thing and I'm just too tired to process it right. I think I'll go kick in a door and go to bed.
Now I'm double glad I posted my comment about readied action and Reaction. I've re-read PHB 193, and it never occurred to me to read it the way you have! I'd been thinking that you got your regular Action, then declared a readied action that would occur (if the trigger occurred at all) on your Reaction. If we put my thinking into play, you'd get both your Action and the Reaction, and the Reaction would pretty much be a second action in one round. There's no disincentive to do that, because the most you're out is your Reaction, while you simultaneously potentially gain two Actions every round (plus a Bonus Action for some of you!).

Your thinking makes more sense. You're saying that you use your Action to declare a readied action, and if the trigger occurs then you take your readied action on your Reaction. That's costly to the character--you get an action, but at the cost of both your Action and Reaction. Stated another way, you can ready, but it costs you something to do it. And even if you ready an action, you still only get one Action per round. Honestly, I like that better. It's less amenable to breaking and being warped into something overpowered. Thanks for the clarification.
 

I had been wondering if you'd tone down some of the torture and slavery aspects for the youngsters!
I toned it down a little. I told them that the drow had beaten the characters for entertainment (because I wanted them to get the full brunt of the drow being evil), but did not tell them that a deep gnome had been flayed for entertainment. There's entertainment, and then there's entertainment. If that makes sense. No need to give the little kid nightmares. She's scared stiff of spiders, so the giant spider in the webbing was probably enough horror for her all by itself. As for the rest, sending two of their characters into death saving throws...no mercy. They left the table satisfied that their characters had nearly died, yet had survived to overcome the drow captors. It was a nice way to finish the session.


EDIT: Thanks for saying you guys are reading and enjoying the journal. Maybe if it were a blog there would be space for comments, which would be fun. But then we wouldn't have everything housed all in one convenient location.
 
Last edited:

Just read the IC. Good post from Kago (great use of inspiration). I'll need some time to do a DM's response that does it justice, so will wait to post until this evening. Sorry for the delay, but work is busy today and there are a number of things that Kago's kicking in the door will trigger on both sides. More soon from me.

Don't forget that you guys can grant one another Inspiration.
 

Yay, hopefully we're finally going to engage the drow priestesses!

Just a quick note, now that Kago and the quaggoth are present, Kamaels readied action is acid splash, not create bonfire - no need for a defensive barrier hopefully! :)

My tabletop group also reads it as readied actions cost the Action & the reaction by the way.
 
Last edited:



Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top