CapnZapp
Legend
Honestly, if I had new players, running PF2 would be near the bottom of my list.
I consider the game suitable chiefly to players that:
a) have no particular attachment to PF1
b) are veteran D&D gamers that love the D&D way of playing ttrpgs. People living and breathing "dndisms".
c) that are specifically hungry for crunch
That is, people who really want a game with d20-like levels of customization and ability to fulfil power fantasy...
...but (even grudgingly) accept d20/PF1 is broken like frak, so another game is needed. Or, as in this case, players who still would LOVE to play d20 characters, but their dungeon master flatly refuse
Players, who miss the days of poring over World of Warcraft forums for theorycrafting which talent best suit their character...
For everybody else, I am convinced 5E is the better game, unless you somehow think PF 1 is, in which case you should totally play that.
For newcomers to the hobby, 5E is so much more accommodating to beginners it isn't even funny to discuss PF2.
Finally, of course, there's the question: "but why play D&D at all?" I am secretly convinced there are at least two types of ttrpgers: those starting out with D&D, and those starting out with other games (be they Call of Cthulhu, Runequest, MERP, or Vampire doesn't matter much).
Edit: Somehow mobile emojis die in the desktop editor...
I consider the game suitable chiefly to players that:
a) have no particular attachment to PF1
b) are veteran D&D gamers that love the D&D way of playing ttrpgs. People living and breathing "dndisms".
c) that are specifically hungry for crunch
That is, people who really want a game with d20-like levels of customization and ability to fulfil power fantasy...
...but (even grudgingly) accept d20/PF1 is broken like frak, so another game is needed. Or, as in this case, players who still would LOVE to play d20 characters, but their dungeon master flatly refuse
Players, who miss the days of poring over World of Warcraft forums for theorycrafting which talent best suit their character...
For everybody else, I am convinced 5E is the better game, unless you somehow think PF 1 is, in which case you should totally play that.
For newcomers to the hobby, 5E is so much more accommodating to beginners it isn't even funny to discuss PF2.
Finally, of course, there's the question: "but why play D&D at all?" I am secretly convinced there are at least two types of ttrpgers: those starting out with D&D, and those starting out with other games (be they Call of Cthulhu, Runequest, MERP, or Vampire doesn't matter much).
Edit: Somehow mobile emojis die in the desktop editor...
Last edited: