Polymorph Other: which do you use?

[Olive]

The polymorph spells were errated in Dragon, and Tome & Blood, but Dungeon at least still seems to be using the PHB versions...

so which do you use?

 

[UnDfind]

Errata plus

The PHB polymorph makes the Druids mad. We've been using the errata, except that we broke it down to creature types (plant, beast, fey, etc...) as different spells. This makes it much more interesting IMHO, as you have to think about the options available to you when you morph.

 

[Olive]

my wizard character pretty much stopped using the spell once the erratta came out... and i think its wierd that the latest dungeon contains an adventure (actually the latest out here...) that specifically says that the spell allows multiple changes.

 

[hong]

I've banned it IMC. Problem solved!

 

[Olive]

I've banned it IMC. Problem solved!

ok... how come?

 

[hong]

ok... how come?

Um... because it's ridiculously overpowered? Because it's hard to adjudicate? Because I feel like it?

 

[Olive]

Um... because it's ridiculously overpowered? Because it's hard to adjudicate? Because I feel like it?

sure all those are good reasons... just looking for a little more explanation.

especially the over powered thing: PHB or T&B version? or both?