D&D 5E (2014) PotA Worth Buying?

[carmachu]

They hit and exceeded that standard with PotA (which is the thread topic). PotA is at 91.5%, with a lot of reviews in. In a comparison: Rise is at 85%, Second Darkness is at 50%, Skull & Shackles is at 79%, Kingmaker is at 70.5%. How is that not them being worthy of mention alongside those adventures? It got the best rating, it had a larger sample size for that rating, seems like it's fair to mention it along side those other fine adventures as also a fine adventure.

Skull and shackles got higher then kingmaker? From what everyone has said across multiple message boards, kingmaker was the second most talked about AP.....Didnt think S&S was that highly rated. Certainly didnt like it personally in comparison to Kingmaker....

 

[carmachu]

I read Shattered Star. It was lacking. I'm not sure I can even pinpoint the problem. I know reading it I didn't feel inspired.

Mostly, its 6 different dungeon delves with a weak link to connect them together. If it wasnt for the shards no reason to keep going to different dungeon delves.