SPOILERS
[sblock]
Johnny Quick was well done.
The Thing was well done, except he went back into the machine too easily to reclaim his Thing form.
Sue Storm worked ok.
Mr. Fantastic worked ok ... except it was never clear how the original miscalculation was made. That should have been clarified in the movie ... Did Dr. Doom mess up the figures, did Reed mess up, or were they both just wrong? And both being just plain wrong seems unlikely.
Dr. Doom worked out ok, although the combination of the metal body, the scarred face, and the metal mask was probably overkill. I would have gone with either the metal body or the scarred face and metal mask. Both seemed to not make sense.
Also, the part about Dr. Doom's problem being a disease didn't make any sense. He had the same sort of mutation as the Fantastic Four had.
[/sblock]