Rate Revenge of the Sith *SPOILERS*

[Hypersmurf]

Besides, its not too hard to consider that before Anakin left for Mustafar that off screen Sidieous told him he was going to save the republic from itself by raising himself to emperor.

Of course, Obi-Wan and Yoda started referring to Palpatine very casually as 'the Emperor' instead of 'the Chancellor' as well... did they even know he'd declared the Galactic Empire at that point?

-Hyp.

 

[Brother Shatterstone]

Of course, Obi-Wan and Yoda started referring to Palpatine very casually as 'the Emperor' instead of 'the Chancellor' as well... did they even know he'd declared the Galactic Empire at that point?

Yes, cause Palpatine declared a special session of the senate and that’s when Obi-Wan and Yoda moved to the Jedi Temple and before that they hadn’t spoken to each other in quote some time. (each had been trying to live.)

 

[BrooklynKnight]

Yes, cause Palpatine declared a special session of the senate and that’s when Obi-Wan and Yoda moved to the Jedi Temple and before that they hadn’t spoken to each other in quote some time. (each had been trying to live.)

there are obviously some cut scenes that might make the whole thing flow better.

 

[Kaodi]

Obi-Wan/Yoda/Qui-Gon

Maybe I missed something, but I thought Yoda told Obi-Wan that he would " teach you to commune with him, I shall. " or whatever the exact quote was? I don't remember him saying you had to practice to become immortal in the Force...

Personally, on first impression, I really liked this scene. It spoke to Obi-Wan actually doing something in the intervening years, other than just watching over Luke, which would of been too clichéd, and doesn't really improve on the plot. Also, him learning that that was possible has *everything* to do with him letting Vader kill him in Episode IV, and with Luke being able to destroy the Death Star. It means there is a connection between Episode III and IV for, " Use the Force, Luke. "

 

[Henry]

I saw it twice this weekend, and enjoyed it immensely. I myself would have to rate it #2 (right below Empire Strikes Back) in my overall enjoyment of all six movies.

Favorite bits:

--The chancellor's rescue - not a wasted moment in the whole Act.
--The sandpeople scream in the background when Palpatine mentions Anakin's massacre in conversation.
--Running down the horizontal elevator shaft, that then becomes vertical.
--Cody and Obi-wan's "friendship" - it struck me as so quick and cold when Cody casually orders the firing order on Obi-wan.

Teh funny:
--I have two pekingeses at home; one reminds me of the CGI Yoda (attitude and all), the other runs and makes sounds uncannily like Obi-wan's riding lizard.
--A fellow watcher stated his wish that Anakin would have cut down Jar Jar. I pointed out to him that Jar Jar had exactly ONE LINE in the whole film, and that line could be considered Lucas' apology for the character's very existance.

Lucas did hit it out of the park with this one, I have to admit.

 

[Droogie]

Favorite bits:

--The chancellor's rescue - not a wasted moment in the whole Act.
--The sandpeople scream in the background when Palpatine mentions Anakin's massacre in conversation.
--Running down the horizontal elevator shaft, that then becomes vertical.
--Cody and Obi-wan's "friendship" - it struck me as so quick and cold when Cody casually orders the firing order on Obi-wan.

All good ones. Notice it was "Commander Cody"? Could that be a reference to a hero from the old serials?

My faves:
--R2 shocking the droid ("ow!) then getting kicked over like a garbage can...
--Staff-wielding droid loses head, keeps fighting, surprises Obiwan...
--Some of the dialogue made me laugh. Obi and Anakin get trapped by the shield:
"How did this happen?!?! We're smarter than this!"
To the Chancellor: "Sith Lords are our specialty."
Dooku battle: "My powers have doubled since last we met, Count."
"Excellent! Twice the pride, double the fall!"

good stuff

 

[Mouseferatu]

--A fellow watcher stated his wish that Anakin would have cut down Jar Jar. I pointed out to him that Jar Jar had exactly ONE LINE in the whole film, and that line could be considered Lucas' apology for the character's very existance.

Did he? I've seen it twice, and in both cases, I heard no Jar-Jar dialogue. I saw him on screen a few times, but I don't remember hearing his voice even once.

What was the line, and in what scene?

 

[Ankh-Morpork Guard]

What was the line, and in what scene?

When everyone arrives on Coruscant after the battle and meets with the Senators, Jar Jar says "Excuse me" at the end when they're all leaving.

 

[Brother Shatterstone]

What was the line, and in what scene?

"Excuse me" and it happens right after Palpatine says that the senate will still press the war until General Grievous is dead and before Anakin finds out he’s going to be a daddy.

I didn’t pick up on it till my third viewing…

edit: Damn you AMG! Damn you! (same time stamp... I think it placed them alphabetically. )

 

[Ankh-Morpork Guard]

edit: Damn you AMG! Damn you! (same time stamp... I think it placed them alphabetically. )

Score another one for me.