Ankh-Morpork Guard
First Post
DonTadow said:But there are inconsistencies??? which are facts???. The only opinions i give is what they could have done instead of the inconsistencies. Again, if you are happy with inconsistencies fine. In my opinion they were a major distraction to enjoying the movie and I prefer for my movies to make sense throughout. In my opinion the movie could have been smarter by taking a bit more time and eliminating the major inconsitencies. I'm so curious as to how the original script for this read.
Every single movie has some inconsistencies. The fact is, for the movie, the only one I really noticed while watching it was the boy living at the end...but even that can be assumed as we have NO IDEA what happened on the other side of that hill. Its just impossible to say.
The part that isn't fact are the 'major' inconsistencies. They aren't major. For you, they may be, but it is not a FACT that they are major inconsistencies. A strong case can even be made that what you note aren't inconsistencies at all, simply how the story was decided to be told and they make perfect sense within their own context.
By the way, I"m sure percentage wise we have more bacteria than water. So if thats your reason for hating Signs it counters you reason for liking war of the worlds.
...but you can't see all those bacteria from space. Really, though, we could make a case for both species of aliens being complete idiots. Only the ID4 aliens really knew what they were doing...but then they HAD to use those IBM made computers and ruin it all.
