RPG prohibited in Brazil?!?!?! aka. Dumb people around the world

Not QUITE the end of the world...

Last year a girl was killed in Ouro Preto. It is a small, historical town some 300 miles from Rio (in another state called Minas Gerais). She played DnD with a bunch of guys (I don't know if there were other girls). Of course, the "misterious" RPG being involved, some eyebrows were raised. The district attorney (a guy who managed to ban Carmageddon from sale) mounted a crusade to find out if RPG lead youths to murder.

Some RPGers, a while later (in another town), asked the police for protection, claiming that the group they gamed with wanted to kill them, since they stopped gaming with them!

In Vila Velha (a town in yet ANOTHER state, some 400 miled from Rio), the local coucil prohibited stores from selling RPGs. A local RPGer heard of this and contacted one of the 3 council members who voted against such prohibition. She said that the motion to ban RPGs had to be vetoed by the mayor, and then the council had to approve the veto. Then the motion would be cancelled. She suggested that the RPGer gathered his friends and came to th next open session of the council, to represent RPGers in general. And so he did.

When the coucnil met again, he was there with over 50 friends who played or were simply sympathetic to the cause. He talked to all 3 members who originally voted against the ban, and then went to each of the other member (some 20 or so) who voted for the ban. Most admitted that they had never even heard of RPGs before voting the ban, so they voted out of ignorance. By the end of the day, that RPGer managed to sway over 15 of the members into voting against the ban after the mayor vetoed it. His next step would be a meeting with the mayor to exlain what RPGs really are and convince him to veto the ban.

Which by the way is against the Brazilian constitution, since it is censorship, and we down here have a historical dislike for censorship (you know, military dictatorship will do that to a country...).

And no, we don't want to ban the Simpsons. But a government official expressed his desire to sue Fox for it, and revert all profits from that episode to support welfare-related social projects in Rio. To be frank, the episode haven't even been aired here (only in October). The media, in general, thinks this official is being silly and making a fool of himself by wanting to sue a CARTOON!

To learn more about the struggle to keep RPGs in good light in Brazil, check out the site http://www.eujogorpg.com.br/ . It's in Portuguese, but Babelfishing it may be worth it.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Hand of Evil said:
I hear they are ready to ban the Simpsons too...

http://www.msnbc.com/news/739338.asp

I really appreciated the comment on France in this article.

Back on topic, it is the lawyer that accuse RPG, not the judge, it is a big difference: in France, RPG has been accused many times, but when it goes into judge or high ranking policeman (or policewoman) hands, those accusation have always been proved to be false, so I do not have great worry for RPG in Brazil.
 
Last edited:

Geez, and here I was actually thinking that I should apply for Survivor and see if I could start up some kind of Live Action Role-Playing game there to pass the time... I have the darn rules for Vampire memorized. :)
 

About the RPG problem...

Well, the situation is not very good, but only in the state where the crime happened.The main problem is for the game´s image, but it´s not that big.
There´s no legal base to a eventual prohibition to the RPGs,
but what can happen is a age classification, like what happened to the games in USA ( and here too).

Oh, and the problem here is happening almost only with White wolf´s books, and other local books that are mostly inspired in the World of Darkness.

Guess what´s the thematic of these books??? Devils and angels, secret societies etc...

So, the problem here is with certain themes, not with RPG in general.
 

Claudio, muito obrigado!

Thank God, Spanish are Portuguese are similar enough and I can read the link you've posted. It's better to read a true local view of the problem. In Spain, ten years ago, after a wild killing, two boys claimed it was a RPG, and most media wanted RPG banned. But the judge had enough common sense to send the two boys to jail and forget about RPG. Even after that, after each 'bizarre' act (unresolved killing, cementery profanation...) media speak abut "that evil RPG"... :(
 

Ukyo said:
There´s no legal base to a eventual prohibition to the RPGs,
but what can happen is a age classification, like what happened to the games in USA ( and here too).

What happened to the games here in the USA. I must have missed that one. Or are you now talking about the little blurp on video games telling what age it's appropriate for - which actually is useful for us parents but which does not really affect their sales too much AFAIK. There is however no age restriction or any such thing on RPG books in the USA that I know of.
 

As another brazilian member of these boards, let me say a few things:

1 - Claudio, great update on the events in motion. Nothing to add here. You did a great job.

2 - I must agree 100% with Ukyo. We don't have many options of themes down here. The most popular RPGs (for lack of option, in my opinion) are all dark settings, dealing with vampires, demons, angels, assassins, manipulation and rituals. If we could only release some historical settings, some light-fantasy, or even some more childish (for youngster) settings for RPG games, it would help improve the overall image. But, as Claudio wisely stated many times, "trends" are dangerous and we have many Vampire, the Masquerade fans. Let's see if things will change with the release of the translated D&D 3rd ed.

3 - Horacio, I'm glad you could read the website

It's not the end of the world. It's about people getting attention with stupid crusades and media gambits.

It has happened before. It will die away...

(Anyone here remebers Mazes and Monsters with Tom Hanks?)

Best,
Marcio Fiorito
 

The Antra said:
It has happened before. It will die away...

Best,
Marcio Fiorito

I hope so, but I'm afraid it will remain "undead".
In Spain, at least, it did remain undead, it remains undead.
What do I mean? In Spain, 8-10 years ago, two boys widly and coldly killed a man, and they said it was a roleplaying game. Media wanted to ban RPGs, but the judge, after some months, said the boys weren't controlled by the game, they knezw perfectly waht they did. That should have shut up the media, but it didn't. Well, even if at lat they weren't banned, RPG have a stigma, and even today, after each bizarre killing, or cementery profanation, or violence againt animals, Spanish media say something like "Maybe one of those RPG is the cause of that horrible act, because as everybody knows, RPG control the mind of young people and changes them into psychos".
So it didn't die. Not fully, at least :( :(
 

The thing is, RPGs are so obscure here that they don't really have an image outside the nickname "Crazy Game".

I fall on my knees and thank God for sending us Peter Jackson. His LotR movie gave RPGs a better image than 100 media campaigns would. LotR is on the Top 10 most sold books for some five months now, and for a while the Top 10 was almost entirely JRR Tolkien and JK Rowlings! That is so unprecedented in Brazil that I can't begin to make you all fathom it!

The only thing needed is to make the larger audience realize that RPG isn't Goth Horror, Medieval Fantasy, Cyberpunk or whatnot. It's a medium, like a comic book, or a movie, or a newspaper. It's a WAY of telling a story, not a STYLE of story.

But hey, the brand new magazine on Tolkien down here said on their cover that JRR Tolkien is the "Father of RPG". But then again, they said that dark elves came first in Records of Lododss War, and not in DnD, so... :rolleyes:
 


Remove ads

Top