Eremite
Explorer
Sandstorm vs Frostburn (oh, and the wiffle ball)
Firstly, I haven't tried the wiffle ball test yet. I may do so after I finish reading the book.
I'm not at the stage of being able to write a proper S vs F critique but I can say the following in Sandstorm's favour:
1. I really like the touchstone sites and the sand-covered necropolis at the end. I can, and probably will, use these in my games almost "as is". Yep, I like them a lot.
2. I also really like the prestige classes and it's been a while since I've been able to say that about a core product. Lots of flavour, possibly slightly overpowered, but very cool nonetheless. The PrCs use the Lost Empires of Faerun format: fewer classes but several pages' worth of information on each one.
Firstly, I haven't tried the wiffle ball test yet. I may do so after I finish reading the book.
I'm not at the stage of being able to write a proper S vs F critique but I can say the following in Sandstorm's favour:
1. I really like the touchstone sites and the sand-covered necropolis at the end. I can, and probably will, use these in my games almost "as is". Yep, I like them a lot.
2. I also really like the prestige classes and it's been a while since I've been able to say that about a core product. Lots of flavour, possibly slightly overpowered, but very cool nonetheless. The PrCs use the Lost Empires of Faerun format: fewer classes but several pages' worth of information on each one.