Nifft
Penguin Herder
Verisimilitude.Moon-Lancer said:I don't know why people have problems with them. can anyone provide a good argument why its a bad thing, rather then venting?
Elves are so long-lived it's staggeringly hard to imagine that they would biologically diverge into practically different species while humanity remains a single race.
If 'fey magic' is involved -- and there's an intuitive-sounding gloss -- then it's better for some people. Including me.

I've gone to great lengths to ensure that (a) the current racial make-up of D&D in the PHB is possible; and (b) there's a good explanation for why those races are on Earth, where they could not have all evolved.
Cheers, -- N