Iron Sky
Procedurally Generated
I just want to point out that although many posters to this thread, myself included, believe both that these feats are too powerful, and that the fix these feats probably represent should be applied to the math through errata, there's a large difference between that correlation and the causation you imply. I most certainly do not think the feats should be given to everyone because they are overpowered.
I think the feats should receive errata because they are too powerful. Period. Regardless of whether or not anything is done about the math scaling problems, these feats should not exist in their current form.
I also think these feats represent an admission by WotC that they didn't intend for the math to decay as it does. Between that, some personal experience, and various anecdotal evidence, I think it's best for the game if the math gets fixed. If you agree, the best way to fix it is to apply it to all attacks for all characters, because any other approach changes the relative balance between various builds and powers.
I'm willing to concede the second issue. Not everyone agrees that it's better for the game to adjust the math. I can respect that.
I'm not willing to concede the first issue. Unless someone can convince me that the feats are not overpowered (good luck!), I will continue to call for errata to reduce their power level. My reasons for this stance can be found in the thread.
t~
This sums up this thread for me. Thanks tiornys, now I can stop coming here! Expertise = banished in my game until they can justify it.