D&D 5E (2014) Survivor Campaign Settings- Birthright Wins?

[doctorhook]

Eberron 16 --Reason #32: The best presentation of religion in any D&D setting

Amen!

Also note: Somehow, this list is back to misspelling "Nentir Vale". "Nentir" is the correct spelling! Please correct in the next vote.

 

[Tectuktitlay]

Blackmoor 20
Council of Wyrms 20
Dark Sun 16 - Because it's the most original setting for D&D, plus...this is survivor, and it's Athas...
Dragon Fist 20
Eberron 16
Ghostwalk 17
Greyhawk 10 - The most obnoxiously DULL setting I have ever played in. Genericbird.
Jakandor 17
Kingdoms of Kalamar 17
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 17
Mystara 20
Nentir Vale 20
Pelinore 14
Planescape 19
Ravenloft 23
Spelljammer 16
Thunder Rift 20
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 21

 

[Rod Staffwand]

Blackmoor 20
Council of Wyrms 20
Dark Sun 16
Dragon Fist 20
Eberron 16
Ghostwalk 17
Greyhawk 10
Jakandor 17
Kingdoms of Kalamar 14
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 17
Mystara 20
Nentir Vale 20
Pelinore 14
Planescape 19
Ravenloft 23
Spelljammer 16
Thunder Rift 21
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 21

+1 to Thunder Rift. If I don't vote for it, I don't think anyone will. It's the setting I wish I had when I was 10. Low-level. Small area fully mapped with 1mile hexes. Lots of adventure hooks. This is your Starter Set campaign setting and a type of product D&D needs to have.

-3 to Kingdoms of Kalamar. I keep trying to read up on why this needs to be a thing but always end up falling asleep.

 

[CanadienneBacon]

Birthright 22 -- Got dropped off by accident somewhere on page 3, but should now be at 22 with my +1
Blackmoor 20
Council of Wyrms 20
Dark Sun 16
Dragon Fist 17 -- Because it has "Dragon" in the title. That's too similar to Dragonlance, which I detest!
Eberron 16
Ghostwalk 17
Greyhawk 10
Jakandor 17
Kingdoms of Kalamar 14
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 17
Mystara 20
Nentir Vale 20
Pelinore 14
Planescape 19
Ravenloft 23
Spelljammer 16
Thunder Rift 21
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 21

[MENTION=58401]doctorhook[/MENTION], you are my hero for eliminating Dragonlance!

 

[Kite474]

Birthright 22
Blackmoor 20
Council of Wyrms 20
Dark Sun 16
Dragon Fist 17
Eberron 17 -- Your all just jealous because we have trains!
Ghostwalk 17
Greyhawk 7 -- *Sips from cup marked "Grognard Tears"*
Jakandor 17
Kingdoms of Kalamar 14
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 17
Mystara 20
Nentir Vale 20
Pelinore 14
Planescape 19
Ravenloft 23
Spelljammer 16
Thunder Rift 21
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 21

 

[Ezequielramone]

Birthright 22
Blackmoor 20
Council of Wyrms 20
Dark Sun 17 - (+1)
Dragon Fist 17
Eberron 17
Ghostwalk 17
Greyhawk 7
Jakandor 17
Kingdoms of Kalamar 14
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 17
Mystara 20
Nentir Vale 20
Pelinore 14
Planescape 19
Ravenloft 20 - (-3) like it as an adventure, not as a setting.
Spelljammer 16
Thunder Rift 21
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 21

I'm on my phone, sorry for the lack of colours.
As you can see in my badges, I wave some flags, Eberron, FR, Dark Sun and Dragonlance.
I don't think Ravenloft should be a setting, it's too much for it.

 

[77IM]

Birthright 22
Blackmoor 20
Council of Wyrms 20
Dark Sun 17
Dragon Fist 18 (+1)
Eberron 17
Ghostwalk 17
Greyhawk 7
Jakandor 17
Kingdoms of Kalamar 14
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 17
Mystara 20
Nentir Vale 20
Pelinore 14
Planescape 19
Ravenloft 20
Spelljammer 16
Thunder Rift 18 (-3)
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 21

 

[briggart]

Birthright 22
Blackmoor 20
Council of Wyrms 20
Dark Sun 18 (+1)
Dragon Fist 18
Eberron 17
Ghostwalk 17
Greyhawk 7
Jakandor 17
Kingdoms of Kalamar 14
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 17
Mystara 20
Nentir Vale 20
Pelinore 14
Planescape 19
Ravenloft 17 (-3)
Spelljammer 16
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 21

 

[Tectuktitlay]

Oops, 2 more points need to be removed from Greyhawk, whoever does the next list. I only removed one point from it, not three, in my above post (#62). My bad.

 

[Duan'duliir]

Birthright 19 Because it was highest
Blackmoor 20
Council of Wyrms 20
Dark Sun 18
Dragon Fist 18
Eberron 18
Ghostwalk 17
Greyhawk 5 Correcting [MENTION=82812]Tectuktitlay[/MENTION]'s error
Jakandor 17
Kingdoms of Kalamar 14
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 17
Mystara 20
Nentir Vale 20
Pelinore 14
Planescape 19
Ravenloft 17
Spelljammer 16
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 21