D&D 5E (2014) Survivor Campaign Settings- Birthright Wins?

[Ristamar]

Birthright 16
Blackmoor 13
Dark Sun 10
Dragon Fist 10
Ghostwalk 10
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 15
Mystara 15
Nentir Vale 7
Pelinore 14
Ravenloft 4
Thunder Rift 15
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 16

 

[Tectuktitlay]

Birthright 16
Blackmoor 13
Dark Sun 11
Dragon Fist 10
Ghostwalk 10
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 15
Mystara 15
Nentir Vale 7
Pelinore 14
Ravenloft 4
Thunder Rift 15
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 13

 

[Ricochet]

Birthright 16
Blackmoor 10
Dark Sun 12
Dragon Fist 10
Ghostwalk 13
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 15
Mystara 14
Nentir Vale 7
Pelinore 14
Ravenloft 4
Thunder Rift 15
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 13

 

[Twiggly the Gnome]

Birthright 16
Blackmoor 10
Dark Sun 9
Dragon Fist 10
Ghostwalk 13
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 15
Mystara 14
Nentir Vale 7
Pelinore 15
Ravenloft 4
Thunder Rift 15
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 13

 

[doctorhook]

Stats and correction time again!

Name #Score# (Votes For/Votes Against)
Birthright 16 (+8/-4)
Blackmoor 10 (+5/-5)
Council of Wyrms 1 (+2/-7)**
Dark Sun 9 (+40/-17)
Dragon Fist 10 (+2/-4)
Dragonlance 0 (-7)
Eberron 0 (+22/-14)
Forgotten Realms 0 (+1/-7)
Ghostwalk 10 (+5/-5)
Greyhawk 0 (+6/-9)
Jakandor 14 (-2)
Kingdoms of Kalamar 0 (-7)
Lankhmar 15 (+4/-3)
Mahasarpa 0 (-7)
Mystara 15 (+4/-3)
Nentir Vale 7 (+2/-5)
Pelinore 15 (+1/-2)
Planescape 0 (+16/-12)
Ravenloft 4 (+20/-12)
Spelljammer 0 (+4/-8)
Thunder Rift 15 (+1/-2)
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 13 (+2/-3)

**NOTE: There was an error in post #202 which incorrectly reduced Council of Wyrms' score by 1 point. Because of this error, Council of Wyrms was INCORRECTLY ELIMINATED. It has been re-added to this list with its corrected point-total (1 point).

ORDER OF ELIMINATION

1. Forgotten Realms Eliminated by the 22nd vote cast (post #38)
2. Dragonlance Eliminated by the 36th vote cast (post #58)
3. Greyhawk Eliminated by the 70th vote cast (post #111)
4. Eberron Eliminated by the 77th vote cast (post #119)
5. Kingdoms of Kalamar Eliminated by the 80th vote cast (post #122)
6. Spelljammer Eliminated by the 101st vote cast (post #149)
7. Planescape Eliminated by the 122nd vote cast (post #183)
8. Mahasarpa Eliminated by the 130th vote cast (post #194)

As before, my own vote will follow in the next post.

I think the biggest Takeaway from this is...(drum roll) EN world should never be in charge of counting votes.

I resent that! Yet, I cannot disagree.

 

[doctorhook]

My daily vote:

Birthright 16
Blackmoor 7
Council of Wyrms 1 <--- CORRECTED
Dark Sun 9
Dragon Fist 10
Ghostwalk 10
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 15
Mystara 15
Nentir Vale 7
Pelinore 15
Ravenloft 5
Thunder Rift 15
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 13

Ravenloft because of that sweet original module, and in honour of that cool new book.
Blackmoor even though I respect it for being the original, it just isn't as interesting as what's come along since.

 

[MechaPilot]

Birthright 16
Blackmoor 7
Council of Wyrms 1
Dark Sun 6
Dragon Fist 10
Ghostwalk 10
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 15
Mystara 15
Nentir Vale 7
Pelinore 15
Ravenloft 6
Thunder Rift 15
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 13

Because the horrors that lurk in the shadows and reflect in twisted ways the nature of man will always be more interesting to me than a game of checking rations of food and water off my character sheet.

 

[ThirdWizard]

Birthright 16
Blackmoor 7
Council of Wyrms 1
Dark Sun 7
Dragon Fist 10
Ghostwalk 10
Jakandor 11
Lankhmar 15
Mystara 15
Nentir Vale 7
Pelinore 15
Ravenloft 6
Thunder Rift 15
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 13

 

[psychophipps]

Birthright 16
Blackmoor 7
Council of Wyrms 1
Dark Sun 8 Hey bro, you gonna drink that?
Dragon Fist 10
Ghostwalk 10
Jakandor 11
Lankhmar 15
Mystara 15
Nentir Vale 7
Pelinore 15
Ravenloft 6
Thunder Rift 15
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 10 for having a seriously whack name and not being interesting enough to account for it's ridiculous page count...

 

[CanadienneBacon]

Dark Sun's ability to survive numerous downvotes perfectly mirrors the survivalist aspect of the setting.

Props.