Its not bad. I prefer to find books on individual styles. They get a lot more in depth on the breadth of techniques and philosophy.Vigilance said:Comprehensive Asian Fighting Arts: the Bible; read it, know it, love it.
Ultimate Martial Arts Encyclopedia (Best of Kung Fu Magazine): Not sure I cited a single article here, but a lot of really interesting reading.
Martial Arts of Renaissance Europe: A really terrific book on European formal combat training. No, Knights didn't just bash each other. The only thing keeping this book from being on par with Comprehensive Asian Fighting Arts is the incredibly dry, dull, dense academic writing style.
I'll need to check this out
Martial Arts Hero (3rd edition), GURPs Martial Arts: Not sources, more inspiration on the level of comparison. These were the books I judged B&F against as I was writing it, and the books I most wanted my book to be a d20 version of.
By martial arts Hero, is that the Ultimate Martial Artist? My name is in that book as playtester. I actually corresponded back and forth with Steve Long recommending books (most of which he had seen) and sending copies of articles on various styles.
GURPS MA is good overall. I like most of the stuff, but I was not thrilled by some of the style writeups. I actually was corresponding on the GURPS boards with Mr. Carella around the time of the revised version. I was surprised at some of the maneuvers that did not make it in to the write ups of specific styles, because it did not appear in his research where as I would have multiple books on a given style with those missing maneuvers being demonstrated.
Last edited: