What Published Modules Have You Run or Played Multiple Times?

[Reynard]

I am actually most interested in what modules you have been a player for more than once, but GMing is valid here too.

Have you played any published scenarios more than once? Which one(s)? Why? How did your experience change? What did you do about "out of character knowledge"?

People often replay other kinds of games. it is essentially require with board games, of course, and many video games are designed with replayability in mind. I am interested in how folks feel about published TTRPG scenarios and replayability.

Thanks.

 

[Theory of Games]

I've run Ravenloft (I6) so many times I don't need the module any more. It's a very contained adventure with a very structured storyline. I'd create a random encounter table and we'd be off and running

 

[sevenbastard]

I've played 1e Tomb of Horror multiple times as a kid in the 80s and once as an adult in the 2010s.

in the 80s I ran UK2 The Sentinel multiple times as it was the first module I owned.

I have about 10 homebrew location based adventures I slot into any new homebrew campaign. Part of a good sandbox is having solid content. So if something does well in one game I recycle it for the next game.

 

[TiQuinn]

Ravenloft and its variation multiple times across multiple editions. Also I've played and DMed a few of the 2e Ravenloft modules a few times, such as Night of the Walking Dead, Adam's Wrath and The Created.

I've played Tomb of Horrors about 3 times.

 

[Sacrosanct]

Lots. Probably a dozen TSR modules. The most were Keep on the Borderlands, Palace of the Silver Princess, White Plume Mountain, Isle of Dread, Sentinel/Gauntlet, and the Slaver Series.

I've never run a post-TSR adventure more than once. I wonder why. I don't think they are bad or anything. I suppose it's length. They don't do drag and drop smaller adventures any longer, we don't replay the newer ones. And time is more limited now than it was when I was a teen in the 80s.

 

[aco175]

The only ones I remember actually running more than once are a couple from the old Mass Confusion 1984 convention. I somehow had these three from the convention and ran one for the neighborhood kids in 87/88' and at a local convention while in the Army in 92/93'. They were old, spiral-ring photocopied things, but were fun. I never had run them for my current group, but my father was there in 84 when we played through them.

I would run LMoPhandelver and the other box Icespire Keep again for a new group. Maybe Forge of Fury again as well, but I have been with the same group for a while now and they already played them.

 

[ProfessorPhobos]

The Haunting, for Call of Cthulhu.

Even TPK'd an entire party once with the bed.

 

[Bill Zebub]

Maybe Forge of Fury again as well, but I have been with the same group for a while now and they already played them.

I ran that as a player after DMing it. I intentionally encouraged choices I knew were bad....

 

[Divine2021]

Sailors on the Starless Sea. I consider it a perfect one shot.

 

[billd91]

D&D modules I've run (or played) more than once and the editions in which I did them:
The Keep on the Borderlands (Basic, 1e)
Return to the Keep on the Borderlands (3e, 5e)
Slavelord series (1e, 3e - technically, I ran A1-3 in 1e and played A4)
Giant series (1e, 3e)
Ravenloft (1e, 2e, 3e)
White Plume Mountain (1e, 3e)