Which sword would you take?

[Numenorean]

I'd say #1.

#1 just seems more focused. It's all about fighting evil, with powers that seem evenly distributed between offense, defense, and utility.

Sword #2 has the same distribution, but the focus is split. It has a lot of its powers based around opposing fire, but its detection powers and sentience seem focused against evil, which doesn't make sense since this sword is supposed to be a "cold" sword, not a "good" sword.

Good point.

FYI they're both ancient elven blades created as weapons aganst evil. Sword #2 simply has a frost brand theme, butg it was still created to battle evil. Thats why it still has several things that lend itself to that goal.

 

[fafhrd]

#2

Fafhrd loves unnamed bonuses.

 

[lonesoldier]

Well

If you are adventuring on the level of the Nine Hells of Baator that is fire-dominant. Then, yes the the frostbrand would be great. But for all around awesomness, I would suggest taking the first blade.

 

[Alzrius]

FYI they're both ancient elven blades created as weapons aganst evil. Sword #2 simply has a frost brand theme, butg it was still created to battle evil. Thats why it still has several things that lend itself to that goal.

Ah, that makes a bit more sense. I'd still take #1 though. It opposes evil in all its myriad forms, whereas #2 seems to be good if you're fighting evil fire. It's a great sword if you're fighting Imix or Alzrius (eek! ), but beyond that, not an optimal choice.

 

[Ao the Overkitty]

See, I'd go with number #2, but I'm weird.

It is the fire resistance (major) that clinches it for me.

 

[Angel Tarragon]

#1. I really like the description of it.

 

[TheAuldGrump]

It would depend on my character - if I am playing a paladin who hunts out demons then number 1, if I am a dwarfen defender who stands fast against fire giants and red dragons then I am all over number 2.

I might give a slight edge to number 2, the frost brand will affect more critters than the bane against evil outsiders, but that is a campaign issue. While it is most effective against fire critters any monster except those with cold immunity will be affected.

The Auld Grump

 

[Jdvn1]

#2. Not only is it useful against Fire creatures, Fire resistance is just often handy. And the +1's to AC, saves, and init? Heal 1/day?

Nice stuff, there.

 

[Tatsukun]

#1 for me, but I'm playing a Paladin right now, so maybe the fact that I'm drooooooling for a Holy Defender is effecting my choice...

-Tatsu

 

[Saeviomagy]

Assuming no specific bias towards fire or creatures from the lower planes in the campaign, #2.

If we're constantly battling demons... duh #1 will win.