Why wasn't that in the movies?

ControlFreak said:
A few years back .. before the movies .. I was talking about Gandalf to a friend who is a big-time purist. One thing he commented on was how Gandalf really doens't do that much that is "magical" in the books. I think we can easily count them here:

1) He made a flood look like white horses
QUOTE]
Just suprised someone hasn't corrected this yet. Elrond caused the flodd. He wears the elven ring of water. Gandalf mantions that elrond still has power in imladris.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

noretoc said:
ControlFreak said:
A few years back .. before the movies .. I was talking about Gandalf to a friend who is a big-time purist. One thing he commented on was how Gandalf really doens't do that much that is "magical" in the books. I think we can easily count them here:

1) He made a flood look like white horses
QUOTE]
Just suprised someone hasn't corrected this yet. Elrond caused the flodd. He wears the elven ring of water. Gandalf mantions that elrond still has power in imladris.

Elrond made the flood, Gandalf added his own "touches"; which were the white horses.
 

Remove ads

Top