Worst Purchase Ever?

[RichGreen]

Magic of Incarnum was one of my favorite 3.5 supplements, actually. My Incarnate's still one of my favorite PC's I've ever played.

It was definitely out there though.

Yep, I played two fun characters using that book. I agree it was a bit bonkers!

I think my worst purchases were Heroes of the Fallen Lands and Heroes of the Forgotten Kingdoms for D&D 4e. Unlike the Rules Compendium (awesome), the Monster Vault (also awesome, still use the counters now) and the DMs Kit (good adventure), I can't think of anything I used from these books apart from a table for magic armour that didn't seem to appear anywhere else.

 

[Satyrn]

Back during 2e, if you were playing with my group or with one of several other DMs I knew, you would have been using it (sort of) if you wanted to play a "cleric"or "druid". Not that you as a player would have been using the book to design your priesthood for a deity. The Complete Priest's Handbook was used by we DMs to build the priests of various deities in our campaigns (with a little modification when necessary).

Even today, as a DM, I will take that book over the 5e cleric, 1/2 the 5e PHB subclasses or any subclass in Xanathar's Guide or Sword Coast.

I would love to have the Spheres brought into 5e so that I can easily give every god a custom spell list.

 

[Greg K]

I would love to have the Spheres brought into 5e so that I can easily give every god a custom spell list.

I am just doing what I did with 3.0- going through the spells and determining which I want for shared list and which spells are appropriate for clerics of a given deity. However, now, I am thinking of using the sorcerer and/or Warlock as a base instead and ditching the cleric (which is my second least favorite designed 5e class)

 

[AkaKageWarrior]

Yeah, the wilderness survival guide was soooo boring.

Otherwise: all of 4e
the only RPG books I ever sold.