Hussar said:
If I was in control of WOTC, earlier campaign settings would die. I'm sorry, but, I'd dump them in the crapper. All the mass of 2e campaign settings like Darksun, Ravenloft, etc, would be licensed out if anyone wanted to do them, or left to rot. There are more than enough original ideas out there for settings without dredging up old stuff and then trying to shoehorn them into new mechanics. Let someone else do the work if they want, but, WOTC should be looking forward, not dredging up history.
Eberron is a breath of fresh air after so many clone worlds that varied only slightly. Focus on something that isn't going to be a massive headache as people bitch and whine about how I'm changing canon. Look at all the complaints about the Planar Handbook from the Planescape crowd.
The old campaign settings are dead, let them rest in peace.
Tsk. D&D owes a great deal to its past, and the old settings are still popular, and I don't think there's anyone saying Planescape wasn't an original idea when it debuted. For clone worlds, you may have a point with Mystara, the default D&D campaign setting at one point, but the rest are very different in tone, themes, and rules. Compared to Spelljammer, Planescape, Dark Sun or Ravenloft, Eberron is still very close to basic D&D.
Yeah, look at the complaints from Planescape fans about the
Planar Handbook. Those fans are
customers. Keeping them happy is pretty much a requirement for successful business.
reanjr said:
I like the way you think. This would be very cool.
RisnDevil said:
Yeah, but what about all the other [kinds of] books the publish? You would rather no more monster compendiums, alternate rule systems [like the tome series], no more heroes of books, little Eberron or FR, and all the rest? That is what it would take to publish "a whole slew of Campaign Classics. Not to mention, wasn't the existence of SO MANY different settings attributed to one of the causes of 2ed nearly killing off D&D?
Not just settings, but entire product lines. TSR was competing with itself, essentially. So, don't publish them any support material, and you should be fine. I know Greyhawk and Planescape, at least, and probably also Dark Sun have enough of a following that such a book would surely be profitable. Strike the right balance between fluff and crunch (see
Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting), and people will buy it for their own games even if they run something entirely different.
But yeah, I'd go for two Campaign Classics books a year, starting with Greyhawk and Planescape. Then, Spelljammer and Dark Sun. An Arabian Adventures book would also be good, now that I think of it.