ZWEIHÄNDER Reforged: Talking With Daniel D. Fox (World of Game Design)

In this interview, Daniel talks about the latest version of his TTRPG and provides a short update on another project, Bryan Fuller’s Hannibal RPG.

In 2018, ZWEIHÄNDER Grim & Perilous RPG won Gold Ennie Awards for Best Game and Product of the Year. Since then, the TTRPG moved between publishers, appearing in various forms including a Starter Kit. Charles Dunwoody interviewed Daniel D. Fox, the creator of ZWEIHÄNDER, in 2021. In 2023, I looked at Andrew McMeel Universal as it reduced its TTRPG presence, including the impact on Daniel D. Fox’s position. Flash forward to 2024, and ZWEIHÄNDER Reforged, the latest incarnation of the fantasy horror TTRPG, is kickstarting courtesy of Daniel and World of Game Design. In this interview, Daniel talks about the latest version of his TTRPG, its connection with earlier iterations, who he’s working with, and provides a short update on another project, Bryan Fuller’s Hannibal RPG.

419735867_883774347084544_844376763268279412_n.jpg

EGG EMBRY (EGG): Daniel, it has been an interesting road to get the newest version of your signature game. We’ll get into the game’s history in a bit, but before that can you share what fans can expect from the ZWEIHÄNDER Reforged Kickstarter?
DANIEL D. FOX (DANIEL)
: Thanks again for the opportunity, Egg. With ZWEIHÄNDER Reforged, we are taking in nearly six years of playtesting and gamer feedback to remaster ZWEIHÄNDER into a tighter package with expanded content. While some of this work is an editorial exercise, most of the writing has been around all-new content, with never-before-seen professions, ancestries, corruption mechanics, a new Scar system as an alternative to death mechanics, and more. Dejan Mandic marks his return as our interior artist and Yorgos Cotronis as our cover art. Eric Alsandor (Spider00x) is our graphic designer. The design team has also been expanded, with Anna Goldberg and Kate Bullock joining me, Adam J. Rose and Nick O’Hare. A number of other awesome writers have joined in from World of Game Design, too. We anticipate the book coming in at around 445 pages, focusing on usability at the game table. As a part of our Kickstarter, we are also working with adventure writers Stephen Radney-MacFarland (D&D/Pathfinder), Kate Bullock (Magpie Games), Khaldoun Khelil (Vampire/World of Darkness), Elizabeth Chaipraditkul (Magpie Games), Richard August (Steamforged), and other writers yet to be announced to produce a series of 12 one-shot adventures for ZWEIHÄNDER Reforged.

EGG: For those that don’t know, what is the core mechanic for ZWEIHÄNDER Reforged?
DANIEL
: The game uses a d100 skill-based system, where you only roll dice when the stakes are high. In ZWEIHÄNDER Reforged, you aren’t a hero. You instead build your character using a lifepath. They begin their story in session zero as an everyday, normal person (as normal as can be in a medieval fantasy horror game) who lived their life until facing a brush with death. This near-death experience left them with a Scar, one that may be spiritual, physical, or psychological. At the start of your first adventure, the character you created is called a survivor, and inevitably drawn to other survivors who have also faced an NDE. ZWEIHÄNDER Reforged pitches itself as a mild to medium “crunch” game, landing somewhere between D&D and Pathfinder. It revels in having over 100 different classes (what we call professions), with a three-tier leveling system where players unlock multiple classes over the course of their adventures. The fight scene mechanics are fun and tactical (think Final Fantasy Tactics or X-Com) and work with theater of the mind and with minis. Spells are bombastic, where failure to cast properly can quickly change the outcome of a battle. Our unified mechanics works across fight, chase, travel, and intrigue scenes. And when the dice don’t work the way you want them to? You can call upon Fortune to change the outcome, but as with all things in Reforged, it requires sacrifice. This meta-mechanic fuels a Fortune/Misfortune Pool that goes tit for tat between the players and GM.

EGG: What is the feel of ZWEIHÄNDER?
DANIEL
: Themes of survival against the odds and emphasizing ordinary people rather than destined heroes. It explores both human cultures and long-forgotten (but emergent) ancestries, positioning characters as survivors of near-death experiences. Every survivor bears Scars that mark them physically, emotionally, and spiritually, leading to adventures of introspection and epiphany. The game delves into societies dominated by superstition and social stratification. Magic is feared and misunderstood, often leading to accusations of heresy and occultism against those who wield it. Overall, ZWEIHÄNDER Reforged challenges the notion of heroism, presenting a TTRPG where the focus is not on changing the world but on how the world changes the survivors, pushing them to the brink of their morality. It emphasizes low fantasy elements and other dangers like disease, injuries, and the psychological impact of trauma. Compassion and resilience against societal decay become a survivor’s greatest strengths in the game. The narrative underscores the importance of Bonds between survivors, their shared struggles against the encroaching darkness, the personal stories of sacrifice, and the quest for meaning in a world fraught with moral complexities and existential threats. Ultimately, we see ZWEIHÄNDER Reforged as a vehicle for catharsis at the game table.

Chapter 1 Introduction.jpg

EGG: Do you see this as a new edition? A revision? Is it backwards compatible?
DANIEL
: Indeed, it is backward compatible. One of the initial Post-It Notes I put on my design board was “No Wasted Books.” Everything we created would be built for cross-compatibility while repaving mechanics that needed to be updated. The shift from AD&D 1e to AD&D 2e is a great example, as is Pathfinder Second Edition to Pathfinder Second Edition Remastered. While Reforged blazes its own trail apart from the original version, we provide conversion notes inside the book and as a downloadable PDF online to help fans transition their ZWEIHÄNDER characters into survivors for Reforged.

EGG: ZWEIHÄNDER is an award-winning TTRPG with a solid fanbase. Why create Reforged instead of sticking with the, let’s say, “proven formula”?
DANIEL
: Six years is a long time to have the same edition of a game. Keep in mind that the book people are using at their tables was initially written back in 2014, underwent layout in 2017, and published in 2018. As the game has grown, we’ve learned from the community about their experiences with ZWEIHÄNDER. We see where the game had mechanical wrinkles that needed to be ironed out. There are some really fun rules in the game that simply didn’t get the airtime they deserved because they’re so deeply buried in prose. There’s also a lot of heavy editorialization we needed to do, from content to sensitivity and highlighting what makes ZWEIHÄNDER so remarkably different from its inspirations. We also know there is fresh content we want to bring to the core experience. So, instead of creating an entirely different supplement, older ZWEIHÄNDER will not be reprinted by Andrews McMeel, so we can move forward with Reforged.

EGG: Who is working on ZWEIHÄNDER Reforged?
DANIEL
: As someone who solely developed over 95% of the original manuscript, I felt the game needed fresh perspectives to make Reforged better than its predecessor. One of our goals is to push for a better reading and gameplay experience around the table and that can only be achieved by a team of veteran and new writers, ones who bring different gaming and life experiences to the proverbial table.
NOTE: Daniel provided an extensive list of creators, but I'm going to call out the Designers - Daniel D. Fox (Lead), Adam J. Rose, Anna Goldberg, Kate Bullock, and Nick O’Hare - as well as the artists - Dejan Mandic (interiors), Eric Alsandor (layouts), and Yorgos Cotronis (cover artist).

Chapter 3 Character Creation.jpg

EGG: ZWEIHÄNDER has been compared to other games including Warhammer Fantasy RPG. Since Dungeons & Dragons pulled from Chainmail and other wargames to create this entire gaming category, TTRPGs have a rich tradition of enhancing concepts from earlier products which results in new games. When you reread the first draft of ZWEIHÄNDER, what game(s) most influenced it? While working on Reforged, do you still feel their influence?
DANIEL
: Without a doubt, Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay was influential in the mechanics development of ZWEIHÄNDER. You can see it in its class-based system. But ZWEIHÄNDER shrugs off its dark “heroic fantasy” inspirations. ZWEIHÄNDER implies that it’s not a zero-to-hero game, but instead, it’s zero to one. This is where we drift from our game being a simple retroclone to becoming its own thing. For Reforged, we wrote up our own Appendix N: a series of lenses that all narrative and mechanics must pass muster for.
NOTE: Daniel shared a long list of inspirations of which I'm going to highlight a few examples like Kentaro Miura’s Berserk inspiring the dark fantasy elements, the Thirty Years' War offering historic accounts, and Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay influencing the profession-based system.

Chapter 6 Talents.jpg

EGG: To that end, ZWEIHÄNDER inspired other games. You’re offering an updated gaming open gaming license so third parties can create ZWEIHÄNDER content, correct?
DANIEL
: While Grim & Perilous Studios has maintained a community-based content library at DriveThruRPG for three years, we are opening up the licensing. In the wake of the OGL, this is the best approach for everyone. Akin to how MÖRK BORG and Dragonbane have done with their licensing, our third-party license is open and free. It takes zero dollars out of creators’ pockets, makes no claim to their creations, and allows them to monetize and distribute beyond DriveThruRPG.

EGG: ZWEIHÄNDER started life at your Grim & Perilous Studios before moving with you when you started working for Andrews McMeel Publishing. Who has the rights to publish the property now?
DANIEL
: While I was working at Andrews McMeel Publishing (AMP), I brought the game to them as an author, as they had the right to publish and license with my approval for other games (like Flames of Freedom, Fever Knights RPG, and the phenomenal Blackbirds The Extinguishing). When I left AMP, I took the rights with me. Given that ZWEIHÄNDER’s fandom is enthusiastic about the game, I knew I could not support the community alone. It had grown too big for one person to manage. Around that time, I met Zac Goins and Jared Nielsen. We had a long courtship as we got to know each other. We played some games, went to a few conventions, and got to know one another. We sealed the deal last year as I sold the rights to World of Game Design, and I now sit on the board of directors.

EGG: Congratulations on being able to exercise your rights. That’s great news. Why was World of Game Design a good fit for the latest version of ZWEIHÄNDER?
DANIEL
: World of Game Design works with creators from independent to mass, from Stockholm Kartell to Tuesday Knight Games, and Marvel to Modiphius. They operate in print, distribution, Kickstarter consultation, and conventioneering. ZWEIHÄNDER has found a home, and World of Game Design has bold plans for the IP. But most of all, they are passionate creators, love games, and deeply care about their people and partners. What else could a creator ask for?

EGG: Circling back to Grim & Perilous Studios, they're going through a transformation as reported in Geek Native's "Grim & Perilous Studios winds down and is replaced by Cannon Otter Studio". How will that impact ZWEIHANDER's community content?
DANIEL
: We have heard numerous times from our fans that the Grim & Perilous Library needs to be more closely aligned with ZWEIHANDER's core game so that creators can get the halo effect of the broader ZWEIHANDER audience. At Andrews McMeel Publishing, there just wasn't that opportunity due to the way the publisher structured the deal. This is why Grim & Perilous Studios became a separate entity owned by Adam Rose during ZWEIHANDER's publishing run with AMP. Once I sold the rights to ZWEIHANDER to World of Game Design, Adam and I had a discussion about how to best service fans and third-party creators with this new deal. We then made a strategic decision to bring the Grim & Perilous Library under the umbrella of the World of Game Design.
As a part of this migration, World of Game Design has opened the door for creators to fundraise and distribute their ZWEIHANDER products anywhere with a free third-party license program. Despite this pivot, Adam and Nick helped design ZWEIHANDER Reforged. Dejan Mandic has joined World of Game Design as a full-time illustrator. But best of all? I have the privilege of gaming with Adam and Nick in our weekly ZWEIHANDER game in Kansas City. We've known each other for over 15 years, they are both dear friends, and I am excited about their future with the new studio. In fact, they just released their first Kickstarter, called Teenage Oddessey, using the Mark of the Odd engine.

EGG: I'm glad to hear it works out for the fans and the creators. That's great news for Dejan Mandic!
Beyond this project, what else are you working on?
DANIEL
: Adam Rose and I are working hard on Gangs of Kahabro, a campaign setting I created during my AD&D days but have been playing for the last seven years using ZWEIHÄNDER. It’s a medieval urban gang warfare setting in the same vein as the film The Warriors, and we are finally bringing it to publication for Reforged in 2025. Zac Goins is also heading development on Dark Astral, a far-flung strange future analogous to the Old Testament. I just wrapped up editorial work on Bryan Fuller’s Hannibal RPG, designed by Zac Goins, Zack Goings (ShadowZack), Andrew Hindenberg, Andrew Bishkinskyi, and John Baltisberger. World of Game Design is publishing Hannibal RPG later this year. It’s dripping with investigative gore, inner darkness, and a 12-course game that’ll please every Fannibal’s palate.

EGG: Thanks for talking with me. Where can fans learn more about this project?
DANIEL
: While ZWEIHÄNDER Reforged is currently in prelaunch on Kickstarter, we encourage anyone curious about the game to head to our Discord. Our entire team is there and actively sharing out art and mechanics of Reforged ahead of release.

426723954_899937805468198_614607142509992839_n.jpg

ZWEIHÄNDER RPG Reforged Edition from ZWEIHÄNDER RPG
  • “The next evolution of the ENNIE award-winning dark fantasy tabletop RPG is here!”
Egg Embry participates in the OneBookShelf Affiliate Program, Noble Knight Games’ Affiliate Program, and is an Amazon Associate. These programs provide advertising fees by linking to DriveThruRPG, Noble Knight Games, and Amazon.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Egg Embry

Egg Embry

Swanosaurus

Adventurer
Zweihander is either a knock off of 2nd edition or it’s a totally different game. They don’t get to have it both ways.
Sorry to belabor the point, but this doesn't make sense. There's a lot of middle-ground between being a knock-off (which means a low-quality imitation) and being totally unrelated. Star Wars is not of knock-off of Dune, but it sure as hell has been heavily influenced by it.
Or, in RPGs - leaving the OGL question aside, because whether there's a license for something or not has no bearing on its artistic merit: Would you say that 13th Age can only either be totally unrelated to D&D or a knock-off? Shadowdark? Everyday Heroes? What about the "re-statements" like Swords&Wizardry or Old School Essentials? You might argue that these are knock-offs, but I wouldn't call them that, because in re-organizing and clarifying the material, they bring a lot of value to the table. Is Mythras a knock-off of RuneQuest? It started as an edition of RuneQuest, but then struck it's own path, and like Zweihänder, it has obviously been built from the grounds up on some of the same principles of RuneQuest (and while I have other issues with the Mythras publisher, I still respect and will defend their great achievement).

I respect the work of the people at Cubicle 7, but I also respect the work on Zweihänder, and fact is: Zweihänder and Warhammer 4 are two very different systems. WH2 and ZH are also very different systems (although maybe a little closer). There's room for all of them. Cubicle 7 invested in the license, which got them the name recognition of Warhammer, and they invested the work to create WH4. I certainly don't begrudge them that, but I also don't begrudge Daniel Fox turning a small profit on the years of work he put into his creation.
 

log in or register to remove this ad


Some Dude

Explorer
Day one pledge for me. I'm currently running a Zweihander campaign for some veteran players, including some old GW employees, one of whom was the first person in the US to get a copy of WFRP (which he still has).

I've heard the "knockoff" arguments, and I don't buy them. There's a lot more daylight between Zweihander and WFRP that there is between most OSR games and D&D. And that was true before the Starter Set. I can only imagine how much more true Reforged will make that.

That having been said, though, I don't begrudge anyone making purchasing decisions based on their morals. I think people should do that, whether their morals and mine align or not, in general or around a specific issue. I've got a "no buy" list of my own, so I'm not gonna fault anyone for that.
 

Swanosaurus

Adventurer
I don’t think it’s moral to take someone else’s work unlicensed - scratch off the serial numbers and throw in some house rules then sell it on. I don’t really care how many hours you put in.

Yes I do think Zweihander is a low quality imitation of WFRP 2e. I think it’s a massive understatement to say it’s merely built on the same principles.
Okay, that's a matter of judgement, and I don't want to talk you out of yours (especially since I'm very much on the fence about how I feel about Fox/Grim&Perilous Studios in general).
Just wanted to make clear that I think that it's possible for games to be inspired by/based on other games, clearly being related to them, without being knock-offs.
 

Aldarc

Legend
Sorry to belabor the point, but this doesn't make sense. There's a lot of middle-ground between being a knock-off (which means a low-quality imitation) and being totally unrelated. Star Wars is not of knock-off of Dune, but it sure as hell has been heavily influenced by it.
Or, in RPGs - leaving the OGL question aside, because whether there's a license for something or not has no bearing on its artistic merit: Would you say that 13th Age can only either be totally unrelated to D&D or a knock-off? Shadowdark? Everyday Heroes? What about the "re-statements" like Swords&Wizardry or Old School Essentials? You might argue that these are knock-offs, but I wouldn't call them that, because in re-organizing and clarifying the material, they bring a lot of value to the table. Is Mythras a knock-off of RuneQuest? It started as an edition of RuneQuest, but then struck it's own path, and like Zweihänder, it has obviously been built from the grounds up on some of the same principles of RuneQuest (and while I have other issues with the Mythras publisher, I still respect and will defend their great achievement).

I respect the work of the people at Cubicle 7, but I also respect the work on Zweihänder, and fact is: Zweihänder and Warhammer 4 are two very different systems. WH2 and ZH are also very different systems (although maybe a little closer). There's room for all of them. Cubicle 7 invested in the license, which got them the name recognition of Warhammer, and they invested the work to create WH4. I certainly don't begrudge them that, but I also don't begrudge Daniel Fox turning a small profit on the years of work he put into his creation.
I think that the issue is that for some people those "years of work he put into his creation" looks awfully lot like the below meme:
ed2.png
It didn't help that Daniel Fox had a tendency to throw a temper tantrum on the Internet when people mentioned the similarities to Warhammer. This is to say, that I think that the author and how they handle criticism and/or interact with others online is also one reason why Zweihänder also often gets flack for being a knock-off where others don't as much.
 
Last edited:

jdrakeh

Front Range Warlock
It didn't help that Daniel Fox had a tendency to throw a temper tantrum on the Internet when people mentioned the similarities to Warhammer. This is to say, that I think that the author and how they handle criticism and/or interact with others online is also one reason why Zweihänder also has often gets flack for being a knock-off where others don't as much.

This. I was a big fan and supporter of Zweihander for a bit, but Daniel's behavior (both with regard to criticism of any kind and marketing his game) eventually soured me on the game.
 


Swanosaurus

Adventurer
This. I was a big fan and supporter of Zweihander for a bit, but Daniel's behavior (both with regard to criticism of any kind and marketing his game) eventually soured me on the game.
That's how I feel ... it's just that I actually like the game. On the other hand, there's lots of other RPGs out there that I like, so I don't exactly need a new edition of ZH. I still can't help but remain interested.
 

Zehnseiter

Adventurer
This. I was a big fan and supporter of Zweihander for a bit, but Daniel's behavior (both with regard to criticism of any kind and marketing his game) eventually soured me on the game.
It is also (at least for me) a far more compelling argument then there being no room for a game that uses the old WFRP rule set as base for its rules. Hell I still remember the constant promotion spam when Zweihänder came out.
 


Split the Hoard


Split the Hoard
Negotiate, demand, or steal the loot you desire!

A competitive card game for 2-5 players

Related Articles

Remove ads

Split the Hoard


Split the Hoard
Negotiate, demand, or steal the loot you desire!

A competitive card game for 2-5 players
Remove ads

Top