Tony Vargas
Legend
That's an interesting new spin on immersion.The issue I had was the prevalence, not its effect on the dice roll. In the games I've played, it's rare that someone isn't rolling 2 d20. It makes me feel like I'm not playing D&D and instead playing one of the many success based systems (WOD, Shadowrun, etc). Breaks my immersion that I'm playing D&D.
The impression I got was that Advantage is not supposed to be quite that easy to get. Most examples of getting it require an action on someone's part, for instance. Hm... not that that would keep most rolls from having advantage, just mean that there'd be fewer rolls as some players decline to roll to get advantage later or give it to someone else...