Will save: 1d20+5=12Roll for me, if you would. +5. Apparently my save bonus in rogues gallery is wrong btw.
Well, since the save was a failure, you can decide to come up with your own description of what you think the worst thing Lorien ever did and post it in the IC thread. Be as creative as you want. The main thing to consider is if Lorien broke a law, was he ever punished for it. That would be key to how the sword will view him.I don't really think Lorien has ever done anything actually criminal. He might disregard laws in moral sense but because of his noble upbringing he obeys basic laws out of habit and self preservation. Then again his neutrality in good/evil axis might mean that he has on occasion disregarded someone else's plight. But I don't think the sword cares for that
The cruelty to animals thing would apply if Caerth wasn't properly chastised for his wrong-doing. I believe your noted in your description that Caerth's druid master taught him to be kind but would he have made him do penance as part of his training?Not sure what kind of "secret shame" would be appropriate for Caerth. I mean, besides the cruelty to animals in his youth, before he was properly raised and trained as a druid. Any thoughts?
Be creative with it but don't feel you have to make the 'sin' a major one. It's up to you.Phar missed his save too. He's a paragon of Elven virtue, but no one is without sin I suppose. Will give it some thought and try to get up a post later today.