It's the poster's misunderstanding of the Initiative rules. That misunderstanding of those rules leads to his idea that he can autowin any of these "duels" because he believes he can act before they can even know he is there, even if they have abilities or items or whatever that mean they cannot be surprised. It's why he's lost both combats which were actually played by the rules.Give me a page number for that.
For someone who claims to know the rules perfectly, he ... doesn't.