Eyes of Nine
Everything's Fine
(Warning, below is 1000% anecdata)
I've run LMoP three times, and my son has started DMing it at least once
Never run KotB or played in it
I did play in B1, which was terrible (but hooked me 46 years ago, and here I still am!)
The only thing I'll add, which maybe has already been said upthread somewhere: The OP only said "played", which I take to mean played at least a session, with session being defined within each individual playgroup.
Completed means something else. That said, LMoP may also be the most completed adventure too...
I've run LMoP three times, and my son has started DMing it at least once
Never run KotB or played in it
I did play in B1, which was terrible (but hooked me 46 years ago, and here I still am!)
The only thing I'll add, which maybe has already been said upthread somewhere: The OP only said "played", which I take to mean played at least a session, with session being defined within each individual playgroup.
Completed means something else. That said, LMoP may also be the most completed adventure too...