Statistically, sure, but accidents are not murders. If man stopped using fire just because some moron burned his house down once, we would not have progressed to the point of industry that we are now, and the idea that an INDEX is going to cause murder remains an astounding claim that should be mocked into oblivion, and most of your post is DEFINETIVELY straw manning and splitting hairs as the source of this was the assertion that an INDEX is somehow controversial, causes gate keeping, or insensitive. Which it's not.
Did I say that? No. Never implied murder. I was actually mixing the index discussion up with the rest rules/ variant rules discussion. Or houserules if you want.
Bad rules put into a game that are not helpful even if they sound cool can make a game unfun.
Someone else was comparing it to weapons. And I just answered that weapons even if they are not dangerous by themselfs and even a tool for some people do indeed pose danger if not used and secured properly.
Good. As would most people. Now what if your child is like I was at 2 years old? At 2 years old I climbed onto the refrigerator while my mother was out of the room for about 30 seconds and started chucking kitchen knifes onto the floor. Gave her a hell of a scare. No clue how I did it, but these things can happen. Is it your fault? Mine? My mom's? The refrigerator manufacturer? The apartment we lived in? None. My point is you can't always place blame or have guardrails. Life is hard, and often unfair. We all live, we all will die someday, and none of us are immune to the consequences of dumb mistakes.
Did I say that? No.
Of course you can't put guard rails everywhere. But you put instructions into medical boxes or technical devices, especially if they can possibly be hazardous.
Which tools? A spoon is a tool. A pencil is a tool. A shovel is a tool. A jackhammer is a tool. An xbox controller is a tool, sir. You cannot place them all into one general category and just ban them all or require special training for them all. And at the end of the day, an individuals carelessness that gets them hurt is THEIR responsibility.
Did I saiy that? Let me read it again. No. Not even hinted at that.
I don't even know how to respond to this. Why? Who? Where? When the playground was built, mayhap, but what are you implying, that people are randomly going around and dropping nails on children's playgrounds? It feels like you are making up extravagant circumstances to try and justify a point.
Hasn't been the forst time someone forgot something after repair work.
Especially of they are careless or in a hurry.
I did not want to use the example of unsecured weapons which are found by children and kill them for sensotove reasons.. Thought you would be able to understand that.
Let me give an example as to why I can never agree with this line of thinking. When I was in college I learned about a particular legal case that basically killed Tiger Electronics. You may remember them, if you're old enough, as the creators of older hand held games like Pox and the original Digimon toys, and the source of this travesty: Tamagotchi. Well, back in the late 90's, a lawsuit was filed against Tiger Electronics. Thanks to this lawsuit, they lost about 200 million and had to place a warning label on all of their products, which looks like a pair of fingers holding a round object up to a peach.
Yeah. I don't think that is a perversion of law and I am happy that this is impossoble where I live.
The origin of this warning label is that a man in I THINK Michigan had purchased a Tamagotchi toy, and for some reason... He stuck it up his anus. It became stuck. He did not tell anyone for about 8 days, and so developed some SIGNIFICANT health complications and the Tamagotchi had to be surgically removed. This man filed a lawsuit against Tiger, alleging that the fault lied with them because they had no warning labels that warned the man NOT to stick the tiny handheld toy up his own bum. Now the part I don't get, and my professor didn't get, was HOW the man won the lawsuit, but he did. And so that warning label was created, and Tiger Electronics never recovered from the loss. Picture is of a Tamagotchi.
See above. I agree with your professor.
The fact of the matter is that some people are just dumb. Some people will, in GREAT lapses of judgement, just make an asinine, absolutely brain dead decision. And there is next to nothing that you can do to stop them. All your attempts to do so only result in people making these absolutely horrendous decisions and then being rewarded for it with millions of dollars. You punish the wrong people, and protect the wrong people. I can't support that, ever.
Yes. This is why I like the new stealth rules for example. Just make a sensible decision and apply rules with good faith and common sense. No stealth rule will protect the game from someone exploiting them or misinderstanding them.
There are still house rules that sound cool bit are causing problems that you don't easily connect with them.
So not including those as variants seems rather benefical.
I can tell you that I have played too much monopoly with cool houserules (I did not know they were house rupes back then). The plain and simple standard rules prove a much better gameplay experience, even if they sound way more boring.
Especially when the source of the drama is an index dude. It's an index. An index is not going to gate keep. It's not controversial. It's an index. I'm gonna go eat dinner now.
Again. I obviously answered to a post I falsely connected to a different part of the discussion. Can happen.
Don't dude me. I am certainly not your dude.
