Do you observe Thanksgiving?

Do you observe Thanksgiving?

  • I'm an American, and I observe Thanksgiving.

    Votes: 55 51.9%
  • I'm not an American, and I observe Thanksgiving.

    Votes: 5 4.7%
  • I'm an American, and I do not observe Thanksgiving.

    Votes: 8 7.5%
  • I'm not an American, and I do not observe Thanksgiving.

    Votes: 38 35.8%


log in or register to remove this ad

It's not really a thing in the french-speaking part of Canada. We do have a holiday for it, but I've never met french-Canadian actually having a Thanksgiving day like the Americans do (family, food, etc). I think it's does happen in the anglophone part though.
 


It's not really a thing in the french-speaking part of Canada. We do have a holiday for it, but I've never met french-Canadian actually having a Thanksgiving day like the Americans do (family, food, etc). I think it's does happen in the anglophone part though.
Yeah, it's not a huge thing here in Vancouver but it's a reason for White Spot and other places to offer turkey dinners to cook at home, for cafes to offer turkey cranberry croissants, that sort of thing.
 

It's not really a thing in the french-speaking part of Canada. We do have a holiday for it, but I've never met french-Canadian actually having a Thanksgiving day like the Americans do (family, food, etc). I think it's does happen in the anglophone part though.
Correct. I used to date a Canadian Ukrainian lady (anglophone Ontario) in the 80s and Thanksgiving was observed.
 

Santa at the end of the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade, and maybe the closest thing to the an official start of the Christmas season in the US?

View attachment 423303
We did Thanksgiving lunch at Fogo de Chao today. Part of the decor over the salad bar included a tree & sign in traditional Thanksgiving/fall hues of browns, yellows, oranges and reds that said “Merry Christmas”.
 

Correct. I used to date a Canadian Ukrainian lady (anglophone Ontario) in the 80s and Thanksgiving was observed.
I think they meant the Anglophone part of Quebec. There are still some distinct cultural differences between the primarily French-speaking majority and the primarily English speaking minority in that province. It's a whole thing that has significantly shaped Canadian history and politics since there's been a Canada. By and large, Thanksgiving is seen as an English-speaking holiday.

It's pretty widely observed in Ontario and other primarily English speaking provinces, but not remotely in the way that the US celebrates it. But it's a statutory holiday everywhere in the country, including Quebec.

British Columbia, where I live, recently added two more statutory holidays so that there is at least one for every month except June, and 13 total. I'm assuming June gets a holiday added soon.
 
Last edited:

I think they meant the Anglophone part of Quebec. There are still some distinct cultural differences between the primarily French-speaking majority and the primarily English speaking minority in that province. It's a whole thing that has significantly shaped Canadian history and politics since there's been a Canada. By and large, Thanksgiving is seen as an English-speaking holiday.
I'm Québécois and the lady I was talking about studied with me at Concordia University in Montréal. A lot of Ontario anglophones study in Québec because it costs less than in their own province.

There are many cultural differences between the primarily French-speaking majority and the primarily English speaking minority in Québec. We are far from being culturally assimilated into the ocean of English speakers of North America.

/end derailing.
 
Last edited:

Similarly, I don't feel like Thanksgiving is big in Germany. However, from the times when I still regularly attended church, I do remember the special mass we had for "Erntedankfest" (harvest festival) on the first Sunday of October, which probably comes somewhat close
Yeah, harvest festival first Sunday in October in UK as well, and I suspect most of Europe. But it’s not a big deal and will probably pass by unnoticed if you don’t go to church.

What I don’t understand is why American Thanksgiving is so late. If your harvest isn’t in by October it will be wrecked.
 

Yeah, harvest festival first Sunday in October in UK as well, and I suspect most of Europe. But it’s not a big deal and will probably pass by unnoticed if you don’t go to church.

What I don’t understand is why American Thanksgiving is so late. If your harvest isn’t in by October it will be wrecked.
I have no idea what the harvest dates were back in 1863 when Lincoln picked a date, or the earlier festivals. But I was surprised to learn just now that corn (edit: maize for much of the world), for example, does finish getting harvested a lot later than I thought:

1764340620103.png

from: A Visual Look at Typical U.S. Corn Harvest Dates | MachineFinder


And a variety of others go through late November:

1764340867955.png


from: Harvest Calendar
 
Last edited:

Remove ads

Top