Recent content by monboesen

  1. M

    D&D 5E Help with my 5th level barbarian Lycanthrope

    My advice. The minute the player seeks to gain any form of advantage from being a homocidal shapechanging wolfbeast is the minute they turn into an NPC. Lycanthropy should never be something a player/character embraces. It is a horrible curse that will lead to killing friends, family, innocents...
  2. M

    A couple of questions

    Great, does it actually spell that out somewhere in the books? Because I thought it might be the case, but could not find it. I do not agree that it will be only part of their arsenal. All their skill points and most of their exploits will be eaten up just to be competent at magic. Which will...
  3. M

    A couple of questions

    Hi Having read the OLD rules and attempted a couple of character creations some questions have popped up. 1. Why is the gladiator the only martial career that grants acces to armor skills? It seems especially strange that the Knight and Man-at-arms careers doesn't get them. 2. Magic seems...
  4. M

    D&D 5E Dealing with a trouble player and a major blow up

    Having read the entire thread I'm hoping that Majoru has pulled a fast one on all of us and is secretely laughing about all the outrage. If not......Majoru you need to get away from these so called friends as fast and permanently as possible. What you are describing does not sound fun, healthy...
  5. M

    D&D 5E What Subclasses would you like to see?

    I fail to see how this figher is not a credible swashbuckler ”Duelist” Human Fighter 1 Str 12, dex 16, con 12, int 12, wis 8, cha 14 HP: 11, AC: 17 (std leather and shield), Move: 40 ft. Class abilities: Second wind (1d10+1 hp/rest) Skills: Acrobatics, Athletics, Deception, Intimidate...
  6. M

    To face or not to face...

    I think we will just have to agree that we disagree. But if you want opinions about specific rules another time it would be helpful and productive is you presented the actual rules you use. Asking about our opinion on the UA rules is kind of meaningless when you actually use a heavily...
  7. M

    To face or not to face...

    Doesnt change the fact that your rules makes shields a bad option, even though shields have been the norm in real life in most fighting cultures. IMO you undervalue the defensive worth of a shield a lot. As for AoO and spring attack. The opponent you attack dont get any, so your house rule...
  8. M

    To face or not to face...

    You see Shields as effective? IME they are far surpassed by two-handed weapon and power attack ortwo weapon fighting and crit fishing. As for the spring attacking rogue, it is not just a fair turnabout. A fighter gains a +2 bonus to attacks when attacking from the rear. The rogue gains the...
  9. M

    Vow of Poverty and Polymorph.... am I being too much of an ass?

    I'll back the prior posters up. With VOP you can NEVER be to much of an ass. By itself it is already broken. And the player tries to stack it with another completely broken part of the rules (polymorph).........:uhoh: He should be happy you dont just tell him to make another character, and...
  10. M

    To face or not to face...

    OK then. So when you asked whether or not we liked the UA facing rules it was largely irrelevant as you yourself have had to remedy them in order to make it work. Your houserules will make facing work better. But you still shaft shield users big time. Shields usually gives a +2 AC bonus vs...
  11. M

    To face or not to face...

    But thats not realistic at all. We tried using the facing rules for a short stint and had the same experience. People continually alternate moving behind their direct opponent. Which in real life combat situations is almost impossible, as it takes far less time and effort to turn yourself than...
  12. M

    How to make a capable druid?

    Druids are borderline broken good to begin with. Adding 4 LA's on top of that. Well all you need to do is to put the highest score in wisdom and the second highest in constitution. Take the feat that alllows spellcasting when wildshaped. That ought to be plenty strong for most campaigns and far...
  13. M

    Player homebrew question

    With stats like that I would say you are way past the point where balance is any concern at all. Let him have his cake and eat it too.
  14. M

    Pathfinder 1E Is there any reason to be cured of lycanthropy?

    You are not turning into a natural wolf. You are turning into a werewolf. To me that's not even near the same thing. So far it seems its you trying to eeke out an advantage of something that should be a curse. My advice would be to go with at all the way. Changing into a raving bloodthirsty...
  15. M

    Pathfinder 1E Is there any reason to be cured of lycanthropy?

    Quote from pathfinder SRD Because you want to play a PC rather than a NPC? Because your character might not not like being infected by a magical curse that turns him into a bloodthirsty beast. Which could easily lead the character to hurting or killing friends and family members. Because...
Top