Riley McClean
Having crawled into shooting position first, Riley takes a moment to make sure his extra bullet tubes for his Spencer are close at hand. When Dakota fires, Riley is ready. His Spencer booms almost in unison with Jeb's big Sharps. Riley wasn't able to pick out any details of the men by the river, so he somewhat randomly chooses to shoot at #17.
Initiative: 14+8=22,
To hit: 17+10-2 for range(Far Shot)=25,
Confirm critical threat due to targe being flatfooted=9+10-2=17.
Darkness concealment=70,
Regular damage=2+10=12,
Critical damage if appropriate is damage x2