Books everyone seems to love, but you just can't

DrunkonDuty

he/him
I also liked The Old Man and the Sea. I saw the movie many, many years ago (Spencer Tracy? I think it was Spencer Tracy.) When I finally read the short story I enjoyed that too. Also enjoyed The Sun Also Rises (or Fiesta depending on where you live.)
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Campbell

Relaxed Intensity
Pretty much any heroic fantasy novel. Lord of the Rings, Sword of Truth, Wheel of Time, Shannara. Any sort of epic quest against huge existential threats. See also standard super heroics found in stuff like the Avengers. I like personal stories. The type of fiction that's about characters who have deeply personal wants and needs they cannot easily achieve. I don't want heroes. I want protagonists.
 

jhingelshod

Explorer
One that stuck out for me as particularly bad was Michael Moorcock's Eternal Champion series. I read and enjoyed the Elric books back in the 80's. They weren't particularly well written, but...ELRIC!! STORMBRINGER!!! (I almost wrote Black Razor there....). I trawled the second hand bookshops in Newcastle and bought pretty much the whole Eternal Champion series....Erikose, Corum, Hawkmoon, Jerry Cornelius.....
I started with the Erikose (I think that was his name) and was pretty unimpressed. The writing was, if anything, worse than Elric without any of the great story and characters, but I pushed on with Corum, like you do. It was, if anything, even worse. Terrible writing and recycled ideas. As far as I could see, Corum's entire personality was "I have a silver hand". I never did find out Hawkmoon's backstory because the whole lot ended up being donated, including the Elric novels which was a shame. I've since tracked down most of the Elric stuff. It's there on my shelf, but I'm not sure I'd ever re-read it.

Let's address another elephant in the room. Conan... I LOVED the Conan books back in the day. They were what I first read, along with Sword of Shannara, in the early 80's when I met the weird kids in high school who got me to roll out my first character (human fighter, made L9, gave me my first twinge of LFQW envy). There was an imprint, by Orbit I think, of about 20+ books and I worked through them all, buying one each month with my pocket money. Loved 'em all. Howard, Offutt, Spague de Camp. Eventually, my wife informed me that we didn't have space so they were donated. A few years ago I bought the Howard Conan stories in hardback and settled down to revisit the pleasures of my youth, which turned out to be a big mistake. It wasn't as bad as Moorcroft, but I couldn't get past the one-dimensional characters, clunky dialogue and poor writing to see the magic that thirteen year-old me had seen. I should have learned my lessons from Blakes 7.....
 

Seems I'm not the only one who liked God Emperor of Dune.

I was 14 when I first read Eddings loved him.

Read alot he gets repetitive.

Elenium is probably his best work.
I've long since got rid of the rest of my David Eddings books, but I still have the Elenium and re-read it from time to time.
 

Zardnaar

Legend
I've long since got rid of the rest of my David Eddings books, but I still have the Elenium and re-read it from time to time.

Belgariad seemed to be aimed at teens, Mallorean a bit to familiar same with Tamuli.

Elenium is his grittiest work I suppose with best characters.

He was my favorite author aged 14 or so though;).

Or as an old player described "Sparhawk greatest paladin ever".
 

Ulfgeir

Hero
Belgariad seemed to be aimed at teens, Mallorean a bit to familiar same with Tamuli.

Elenium is his grittiest work I suppose with best characters.

He was my favorite author aged 14 or so though;).

Or as an old player described "Sparhawk greatest paladin ever".

I agree that Elenium is his best work. But that is also his only work where he doesn't use the exact same template over and over. And he also stole that whole plot from Raymond E. Feist if I recall correctly.
 

Zardnaar

Legend
I agree that Elenium is his best work. But that is also his only work where he doesn't use the exact same template over and over. And he also stole that whole plot from Raymond E. Feist if I recall correctly.

Silverthorn? Go recover the cure for the poison?

I don't think it's possible to write a truly unique concept in fantasy/sci fi anymore just clever variations.

Heh my originals from the 90's. I covered them in plastic as a teen don't think I've read them since the 90's.

IMG_20210128_235714.jpg
 
Last edited:

I will give Hemmingway credit for his taste in cocktails. Both The Death in the Afternoon and the Hemingway Daiquiri are tasty beverages.

I love The Old Man and the Sea!

One thing about The Elenium is that it showed that a paladin could be something other than a lawful stupid stick-in-the-mud that is just waiting for an excuse to attack the party's thief. That they could be someone with a sense of humor, be actually kind, and be willing to bend the rules at least a little.

Or as an old player described "Sparhawk greatest paladin ever".
 



Remove ads

Top