Knightfall
World of Kulan DM
No, I was basing the result off of The Butcher's AC. (I saw the Nat. 20, but I was still waking up.) I even rolled the miss chance and then crossed it out.I wouldn't ask normally, but you have the natural 20 in one roll marked miss...
D20+12-8 = [20]+12-8 = 24 (miss)
I probably missed miss chance roll somewhere, but maybe... ?
However, he failed his Dexterity check on his first crit., so the dagger slipped out of his hand. The most he could do is try to punch The Butcher in the leg. That's an unarmed strike, which provokes an AoO. The Butcher could counterstrike, if he has Combat Reflexes. While I know if he does or not, Camburn doesn't. He prone on the ground and was already dying once. I don't think it is a risk that he'd be willing to take.