Search results

  1. W

    Pathfinder 2E Pathfinder 2 and the two dichotomies

    I think this myth has been dispelled.. D&D Next Playtest hit the public in May 2012. From the PF2 team, Bonner was still at Wizards at that time, having just released War of the Spider Queen. Radney-MacFarland, IIRC, also has things out there on social media which indicate experience with...
  2. W

    Pathfinder 2E Is It Time for PF2 "Essentials"?

    Not entirely true. As someone active on those forums particularly the PbP ones, PF2E recruitment is fairly anemic. It used to be that every day you'd have a dozen games opening up for PF1e PFS games that would play out. Another area where things have dried up is folks engaged on the...
  3. W

    Pathfinder 2E Is It Time for PF2 "Essentials"?

    I feel like folks don't seem to grasp that the sales don't matter. Again this is about the people not Paizo LLC. Paizo isn't part of a public company with shareholders like Hasbro/Wizards with consequences not hitting sales targets. They were a small operation that burst in a window of...
  4. W

    Pathfinder 2E Is It Time for PF2 "Essentials"?

    To further put this into context, Paizo is just a teeny tiny company in the world. Remember they were just printing magazines and running an online game store like MiniatureMarket or TrollandToad - you can still buy things like Ticket to Ride or minis from Paizo, it's just they quote 38 days...
  5. W

    Pathfinder 2E Regarding the complexity of Pathfinder 2

    "Run as written" is an important thing in Paizo-land, particularly because of the development of the broader gaming culture Paizo cultivated in its wider playerbase via adventures and Pathfinder Society. The goal for organized play was to ensure a consistent experience through adventures...
  6. W

    Pathfinder 2E Regarding the complexity of Pathfinder 2

    Ugh, double post. But I'll use the opportunity to cite another example from gameplay. Party is facing an enemy wizard and throws silence on the frontline fighter who rushes up to corner the wizard. The wizard, panicked just as much by the warrior in his face as the delivery of the silence...
  7. W

    Pathfinder 2E Regarding the complexity of Pathfinder 2

    I haven't jumped in on PF2 threads in some time since the game failed to win over the group and we've reverted back to 3e/PF1 or 5e in the cases where we wish to scratch rules-heavy itches vs "just sit down and game" itches. PF2 is definitely regarded by our group as "rules play" - great if you...
  8. W

    D&D 3E/3.5 Uses for Nystul's Undetectable Aura?

    Quararantine eyes... make.. 2002 and 2020 look similar!
  9. W

    D&D 3E/3.5 Uses for Nystul's Undetectable Aura?

    We had good success on a Glove of Storing with NUA to get into a 'no magic party' along with a Bag of Holding with other important magic items to support basement infiltration. In a world with a lot of magic, you'd have to assume paranoid rulers and nobles would be spamming Detect Magic with a...
  10. W

    D&D and the rising pandemic

    Cool thread. Guys, it's in our hands as members of the public to stem the spread. Stay home if you can the next 2 weeks and help prevent the USA from following Italy in measures. It's not about you, it's about your neighbors.
  11. W

    Pathfinder 2E Release Day Second Edition Amazon Sales Rank

    I'm not sure what the infatuation is with Amazon sales rank for a niche category - there's a steep decay for daily units where position #15+ could be going days without a single unit sale in the US as long as there was a steady but low demand for the product. Here's a rough layman explanation...
  12. W

    Pathfinder 2E Release Day Second Edition Amazon Sales Rank

    It will be tough. I'm in reach of 3 metro regions with a combined population of 21M where there used to be a thriving PFS community with over 500 players each month on a Saturday gameday. Now the stores aren't even interested in hosting and there's probably only 16 unique players playing both...
  13. W

    Pathfinder 2E Release Day Second Edition Amazon Sales Rank

    I'm not sure how much I'd obsess over Amazon Fantasy Gaming rankings. Gaslands Refueled is up at #15 and Realms of Runeterra pre-sell is up at #2. As far as all the others books - the Bestiary, Lost Omens Guide, etc... they're all behind the Fallout Cookbook lauched over a year ago, so we're...
  14. W

    D&D General How Long Does It Take to get Sick of an Edition?

    1E I'd probably try and scratch that itch by playing 2E first. 2E I want to say I had a good run, giving it 12 years before switching only to 3.5E and avoiding the 3.0 books. I'd still go back and play 2E again, THACO and all if an opportunity presented but it would be a casual thing, I...
  15. W

    Pathfinder 2E Here's The Official Pathfinder 2E Character Sheet

    Ah, I wouldn't try to convince you otherwise but in the 3E era I've been using them with good results. In the last half-dozen or so 3E campaigns they are all essentially banked to "cheat death" when players fall in love with particular characters and Raise Dead is prohibitive. Cheat Death we...
  16. W

    Pathfinder 2E Here's The Official Pathfinder 2E Character Sheet

    "Hero points" have been around for a while. A form was in the 3e Unearthed Arcana called "Action Points". They're in the 5E DMG. I want to say I remember using them even back in 2E but unsure if it was an official supplement or something from Dragon Magazine.
  17. W

    Pathfinder 2E Pathfinder Second Edition: I hear it's bad - Why Bad, How Bad?

    It's obfuscated in the rules & hidden to the super casual reader ~ Warped Terrain or Dragon Claws are essentially "per encounter set" but instead as focus powers that recharge in between encounters. Translation: A resource at the GM discretion if it resets or not. As opposed to 4E which...
  18. W

    Is Pathfinder 2 Paizo's 4E?

    While we love our ENworld team, it's telling that A Touch More Class (for 5E) had 2630 backers and Paizo/Legendary's Kingmaker (for PF2, PF1 & 5E) had 2347 backers (and has had a longer opportunity to secure that number and a CRPG audience to feed off). Or a 5E campaign setting in the...
  19. W

    PF2 and the adventure day

    They kind of lucked into their prominent position the first time around rather than had a plan to get to get there. So many groups weren't ready to give up on 3E yet and 4E wasn't the product they were looking for. They had feedback from a lot of their fans like "yes! 3e lives!" and they took...
  20. W

    Pathfinder 2E Pathfinder Second Edition: I hear it's bad - Why Bad, How Bad?

    As someone who played a ton of PFS organized play, it's pretty clear to me where the genesis of a lot of these rules came from. You'd have GM and player strangers sitting at a table and there were tons of players who really worked hard to maximize their pre-buffs. I was part of at least...
Top