D&D General 1s and 20s: D&D's Narrative Mechanics

[Maxperson]

Players can do whatever they want IF the GM gives them the space to do it. Which is why I suggest rolling a "1" or a "20" should be nothing special. Or if those rolls are defined as "crits", what happens should be clearly determined during Session 0

I don't personally see an issue with the bolded statement. If the players want to do that and the DM is okay with it, why shouldn't a 1 or 20 allow players to do stuff like that? I wouldn't play that way, even though 1s and 20s are special in my game, but a group that is more narrative oriented and enjoys players coming up with stuff when a 1 or 20 is rolled seems fine by me. The important part is for the group to be having fun.

I'm posting exclusively for the novice GMs who could run into issues. Experienced GMs will probably have a handle on this. Maybe.

I learned the hard way as a 13 year old learning 1e without help. I think running into issues is fine. You learn from the mistake and come up with something better for you and your group. Either by dropping whatever it is that created the issue, or tweaking the house rule into something that better fits the DM/Group vision. I'm not really a fan of rules designed to keep mistakes from being made. Mistakes aren't usually a serious issue.

 

[AlViking]

What does?

If you say that a die roll of 5 or lower fails and 15 or better always works, then for half the rolls proficiency is not counted. Take the example of an athletics check Bobby the Barbarian has a +8 to his athletics, he should never fail a DC 5 check even on a 1. Presto the Wizard has a -1 to his athletics so if the DC is 15 they would fail an athletics check by 1 when they roll a 15 if you are following the rules. Meanwhile for some truly difficult tasks of say a 20 or or higher, some people simply shouldn't be able to accomplish it. When the characters are higher levels, sometimes you can have DCs of 25 or higher so you need to be highly skilled and a bit lucky to succeed.

It's a significant difference to whether or not proficiency matters. It's fine if it works for you I would just disagree that it's a good house rule.