Wormwood said:I hadn't considered minotaurs at all. They would be PERFECT as a brute race (once mechanically balanced), without all that Tolkien baggage associated with orcs.
Yep, exactly, I would like to see the removal of Halflings. Half-elves, Orcs, and Half-orcs from the core – too setting specific (Middle-Earth). Just like I don't want Melniboneans in my PHB.
Dwarves, elves and gnomes all have a historical/mythological precedent, they are not the work of one man.
Don't get me wrong, I'm a HUGE Tolkien/Middle-Earth fan, I just would prefer to use things like Halflings and Orcs when running a Middle-Earth campaign.