DND_Reborn
The High Aldwin
Which a lot of groups are willing to do because they feel it adds to their games and so I suggested a variant for the OP. Regardless of which method you use, if you want to roll every round and are happy with the results, what does it matter? This is why rolling each round, and speed factors, were offered as variants in the DMG for initiative.that means rolling initiative EVERY.SINGLE.ROUND. That is a huge time sink and too much micromanagement.
Now, we abandoned rolling each round a long time ago and I agree with you that it does take time away from the game. But in prior years, we rolled every round and it worked fine because the table was experienced and we could handle it quickly. With my current group, most of the players are relatively new, and so it was too slow to roll every round.