Anthony Valterra vs. Tracy Hickman

[herald]

So do you think these indistry giants will spar on the erotic D&D issue? And what do you think the outcome will be if they do.

Tracy made his thoughts known on the Book of Vile Darkness, so will there be a response from him. We will have to see.

 

[The Sigil]

Other.

Tracy will make a statement.

Anthony will make a reply.

There will NOT be the same heated firestorm from either of them that we saw in BoVD.

Regardless of the actual substance and/or logical merits of the arguments presented, those who want "mature material" in their gaming - the same ones that have been enthusiastic about Vile content in Dragon and Dungeon - will say that Anthony took Tracy behind the woodshed.

Regardless of the actual substance and/or logical merits of the arguments presented, those who don't want "mature material" in their gaming will say that Tracy took Anthony behind the woodshed.

Because (at least on these boards) a greater number of people seem to prefer "mature material," the vote will be that Anthony took Tracy behind the woodshed.

Nobody will realize that it's a matter of opinion and neither one can really "take the other out behind the woodshed" when you're arguing OPINION instead of COLD LOGICAL FACT.

--The Sigil

 

[Hand of Evil]

So this is the next celebrity boxing match for GENCON!

 

[buzz]

Oh, so fake

I voted "Other" because Valar Productions is obviously a prank, so no debate will be necessary.

Why anyone would believe this product is for real is beyond me.

 

[herald]

Other.

Tracy will make a statement.

Anthony will make a reply.

There will NOT be the same heated firestorm from either of them that we saw in BoVD.

Regardless of the actual substance and/or logical merits of the arguments presented, those who want "mature material" in their gaming - the same ones that have been enthusiastic about Vile content in Dragon and Dungeon - will say that Anthony took Tracy behind the woodshed.

Regardless of the actual substance and/or logical merits of the arguments presented, those who don't want "mature material" in their gaming will say that Tracy took Anthony behind the woodshed.

Because (at least on these boards) a greater number of people seem to prefer "mature material," the vote will be that Anthony took Tracy behind the woodshed.

Nobody will realize that it's a matter of opinion and neither one can really "take the other out behind the woodshed" when you're arguing OPINION instead of COLD LOGICAL FACT.

--The Sigil

Good point. Still I'm just interested on how this will turn out.

 

[Belen]

How is sex and gore mature? It's only "mature" because the kiddies cannot see it. However, if it would make a middle school kid giggle, then it is probably not a good idea.

I wish we'd see some real mature content!

 

[JacktheRabbit]

What is mature content?

I mean Tracy was one of the two people who brought us DragonLance. That series of novels had brutal death, massive destruction, rape, and finally the tortured death of the entire world in an appocalyptic alternate world cataclysm. It also had the perversion of the soul (creation of draconians).


So is Tracy anti-mature topic? or is Tracy's religious opinions color his statements?

 

[diaglo]

I agree with The Sigil

 

[herald]

Other.

Tracy will make a statement.

Anthony will make a reply.

There will NOT be the same heated firestorm from either of them that we saw in BoVD.

Regardless of the actual substance and/or logical merits of the arguments presented, those who want "mature material" in their gaming - the same ones that have been enthusiastic about Vile content in Dragon and Dungeon - will say that Anthony took Tracy behind the woodshed.

Regardless of the actual substance and/or logical merits of the arguments presented, those who don't want "mature material" in their gaming will say that Tracy took Anthony behind the woodshed.

Because (at least on these boards) a greater number of people seem to prefer "mature material," the vote will be that Anthony took Tracy behind the woodshed.

Nobody will realize that it's a matter of opinion and neither one can really "take the other out behind the woodshed" when you're arguing OPINION instead of COLD LOGICAL FACT.

--The Sigil

Good point. Still I'm just interested on how this will turn out.

 

[herald]

What is mature content?

I mean Tracy was one of the two people who brought us DragonLance. That series of novels had brutal death, massive destruction, rape, and finally the tortured death of the entire world in an appocalyptic alternate world cataclysm. It also had the perversion of the soul (creation of draconians).


So is Tracy anti-mature topic? or is Tracy's religious opinions color his statements?

Tracy was vocally anti-mature.