Avast ye Landlubbers! What be your bestest Pirate Movies!

[Gomez]

Come on you dogs! Wench up the yard arm and scrub the decks! And tell me what be ye top 10 Pirate movies of all time! ARRRRRGGGHHHH!!!

 

[Gomez]

1. Captain Blood - THE Pirate Movie!
2.The Sea Hawk
3. Pirates of the Caribbean
4. Treasure Island
5. The Crimson Pirate
6. Peter Pan
7. Yellow Beard
8. The Buccaneer
9. The Black Swan
10. Against all Flags

 

[ThirdWizard]

Muppet Treasure Island.

I don't think I've actually seen 10...

 

[The Grumpy Celt]

Sense and Sensibility and scruvy dog what says diffn't 'll walk ta plank!

 

[Tonguez]

1. Captain Blood
2. The Adventures of Sinbad
3. Pirates of the Caribbean
4. Treasure Island
5. Star Wars (Han Solo be a Pirate, a dun ye dogs be sayin otherwise!)
6. Yellow Beard
7. Peter Pan
8. Mad Max (Aye ye scurvy lot a pirate movie again even if there be no water in sight!)
9. The Princes Bride
10. Goonies

 

[Desdichado]

What?! No Cuthroat Island?

I don't remember that movie actually being that bad, actually. I may have to watch it again just to see why it is that this is the biggest flop of all time.

 

[Black Omega]

Pirates of the Caribbean is the only pirate movie I've enjoyed.

 

[Desdichado]

Pirates of the Caribbean is the only pirate movie I've enjoyed.

I've enjoyed a few, but none that aren't already on the list. Captain Blood, the Sea Hawk and The Black Swan are probably my favorites, but the Treasure Island that has Charleton Heston and Christian Bale is really good too.

Then comes Pirates of the Caribbean.

 

[Angel Tarragon]

1) Treasure Island
2) Captain Blood
3) Pirates of the Caribbean
4) Pirates of the Plains
5) Goonies

 

[Templetroll]

I've liked several of those already mention so I'll go over what hasn't been mentioned and most likely wouldn't be....

The Pirate Movie rollicking fun.

Blackbeard's Ghost funny Disney movie

The Ghost and Mrs. Muir Good movie, good TV show. I dunno why I like ghost pirates.

Bluebeard Let's face it, Raquel Welch, Joey Heatherton, Virna Lisi, Sybil Danning and several other European starlets were the main reason I always liked this film but it is fun in its own right. the only pirate link is the title....