I would trade my left arm for an entire campaign world of Gothic horror.
I don't see why it would. One, the written material (for instance, Strahd's history in I, Strahd) doesn't suggest it. Two, the entire reason the Mists took him was because his behavior was so hideously evil; hardly seems likely if he was just another example, or even a slightly more extreme example, of what was going on around him. (And heck, it was the same powers that drew him and Barovia into the demiplane, at least by implication, as transformed him into a vampire in the first place. It's not like he was already some undead horror who was then snatched away.)
I'm sure the world would have some horrific aspects to it, but no more so than Oerth, Eberron, or, well, Earth.
Read more: http://www.enworld.org/forum/showthread.php?480765-Barovia-s-world/page2#ixzz430qcmYxh
So apparently Barovia was enshrouded my mists, ripped from the world it was part of, and is now a demiplane.
Do we know anything about the world Barovia was once part of? Are there any supplements or Dragon articles about it? From reading Curse of Strahd I am getting a sense that this world was sort of a low-magic, low-monster world, where demihumans are uncommon in human lands, and closer to a Renaissance social and tech level. But do we know anything specific?
All of which would be a perfectly fine campaign world. I'd like to see it myself.
I was simply saying we've never seen anything to suggest that Barovia's home plane is that world.
So - we want a world that is still D&D, but where being cursed to be immortal and repeat the death of your beloved isn't something that people will even believe happens, and certainly not something that adventurers will go out and try to 'solve'.
Did you get in on this? Not an entire world, but a large city nonetheless. I went for the 5e version. Before I knew the postage cost to Europe (gulp).
https://www.kickstarter.com/project...e-blight-richard-petts-crooked-ci/description
All of which would be a perfectly fine campaign world. I'd like to see it myself.
I was simply saying we've never seen anything to suggest that Barovia's home plane is that world.