I wouldn't put any of the pixar movies on the list by default. Kids movies can have wild and crazy concepts and still work really well, and they aren't that outrageous compared to the successful Disney movies before them.
I would pick:
Orville: This looked terrible when I saw the trailers. Star Trek with toilet humor? And yet...this show has the heart of Star Trek more than any show since Voyager to me.
Rocky: Its an action movie about a bum who is a bad boxer, one that Stallone scrapped together on nickel and dimes, and it launched him to stardom.
The 100: Ignoring the horrendous finale season, the 100 was the CW show that broke the CW mold for me. I go in expecting Teen drama in space, and yet I'm hit with the impacts of genocide, real life or death consequences for the main characters, dealing with suicidal depression...holy crap this show had some deep stuff!
Riverdale: This is one of those very polarizing shows. Some people completely deplore this show, but for those who like it, it should not work, its crazy....bonkers really, with a plot that looks like three writers got black out drunk in a room one night and then picked up the pieces of the stuff they thought was too out there. And yet....its just works somehow, and its insanely engaging. Its very hard to explain.