So, can we split this off into a slightly different direction than bag-o-rats?
If the fighter is taking on two non-minions. Say a pair of Dragonshields, for instance. If he uses his cleave attack on the first and pings the second for 3 damage, can he mark both of them? My inclination is to say no, because he didn't attack the second Dragonshield, he only splashed it with damage. On the other hand, he damaged it, so he did sort of attack it.
If the fighter is taking on two non-minions. Say a pair of Dragonshields, for instance. If he uses his cleave attack on the first and pings the second for 3 damage, can he mark both of them? My inclination is to say no, because he didn't attack the second Dragonshield, he only splashed it with damage. On the other hand, he damaged it, so he did sort of attack it.