"Shhh, shhh... you're stronger than them, you know you are," Eugene says comfortingly.
Adon and the others, if they care to look through the box, can discover what Agatha saw within. Adon's scholastic eyes see that several of the journals and pictures resemble some of Eugene's collected works on the occult, albeit fragmented. Arthur notices a curious pattern in the deaths. He can't quite put his finger on it, but it almost seems that the causes of death are in some kind of cycle... like the records were doctored somehow. It's not very clear, but it does ring some bells.
Daisy finds a mostly-intact journal and begins to leaf through it. However it's not what's on the inside, but what's on the outside that catches her attention. The book has spots of mold on it, and has a curious flat imprint on the front. It tickles her brain for a moment, and then finally she has it! She once filched a box of jewelry that bore the same marks on its top. It was hidden in a basement, shoved behind a loose brick in the wall.