azmodean
First Post
I wouldn't worry too much about lvl 1 characters coming back, what lvl 1 character is going to have 5,450gp (total cost to have a raise dead cast) anyway?
Another way to look at it, you just lost 5,450gp+ from being raised, if you lose a level, you have been pushed back some in both level and equipment, if you get rid of the level loss, the character is still going to be the higher level, but very poor for their level, which disturbs game balance somewhat. (not really game balance, but the ability of a DM to just look at the character's level and know something about how strong they are. If you are a "weak" lvl 3, then the DM is a bit more likely to overwhelm you)
What it really comes down to though is that some people are for and some people are against. I think the default in that case should be to go with the RAW. (I'm not just saying that because I agree with the RAW in this case, I promise.)
Another way to look at it, you just lost 5,450gp+ from being raised, if you lose a level, you have been pushed back some in both level and equipment, if you get rid of the level loss, the character is still going to be the higher level, but very poor for their level, which disturbs game balance somewhat. (not really game balance, but the ability of a DM to just look at the character's level and know something about how strong they are. If you are a "weak" lvl 3, then the DM is a bit more likely to overwhelm you)
What it really comes down to though is that some people are for and some people are against. I think the default in that case should be to go with the RAW. (I'm not just saying that because I agree with the RAW in this case, I promise.)