Detail Discussion

[Patlin]

Continuing my push on getting folks to look at the proposals, I should also mention input is desired from non-judges as well.

*Gets on soapbox*

Many judges delay voting in hopes of getting feedback, and all insight is appreciated. Come say why any given proposal is great or horrible! Your opinion matters!

 

[stonegod]

Here's the rule on voting, so a 3 to 1 vote would indeed pass.

Stonegod: I think we're talking about slightly different things. Since I'm not an LEB judge, I don't get to vote on proposals here anyway. Therefore, if all four judges vote on one of my proposals, a single no vote isn't fatal. That's all I'm saying.

No, we're saying that if Rystil proposed something, then only Bront, KO, and myself could vote on it (so it would need all three of us to say yes). This is why RA isn't proposing anything.

 

[Patlin]

No, we're saying that if Rystil proposed something, then only Bront, KO, and myself could vote on it (so it would need all three of us to say yes). This is why RA isn't proposing anything.

Yes, I agree with that. Sorry, I thought you were responding to a different point in the thread.

 

[Rystil Arden]

Yes, I agree with that. Sorry, I thought you were responding to a different point in the thread.

You are also technically correct about the votes, but as I've seen in LEW, just the presence of the No makes getting it accepted less likely, even if it needs the same number of votes as before.

 

[stonegod]

I've added my 2 cents to the various open proposals now.

 

[Bront]

Problem:

We have moved into the realm of "Approved content in which I have no access to"

We have already had the problem of people submitting things and not labling the source, which means I need to dig around in books (a pain).

I will not be capable of being an approval judge if I can't check the rules.

 

[Heckler]

First off, I hope this is in the right place and hasn't already been addressed elsewhere.

I was looking at making a character here when I noticed what I assume is an oversight. From CAdv the Scout class and several feats have been approved. However, the scout recieves bonus feats off of a specific list (similar to a fighter), some of which are from CAdv but are not listed among the approved feats.

Or since scout is approved are the scout feats assumed to be approved also?

The feats in question are:
Brachiation
Danger Sense
Hear the Unseen
Improved Swimming
Quick Reconnoiter

 

[Rystil Arden]

First off, I hope this is in the right place and hasn't already been addressed elsewhere.

I was looking at making a character here when I noticed what I assume is an oversight. From CAdv the Scout class and several feats have been approved. However, the scout recieves bonus feats off of a specific list (similar to a fighter), some of which are from CAdv but are not listed among the approved feats.

Or since scout is approved are the scout feats assumed to be approved also?

The feats in question are:
Brachiation
Danger Sense
Hear the Unseen
Improved Swimming
Quick Reconnoiter

None of those feats is yet approved.

 

[stonegod]

You'd have to propose them yourself (start a new thread for such a purpose).

 

[stonegod]

BTW: Do we have anymore adventures in the pipe? KO is running his; where there any other? Folks may want to consider something since we have critical mass in the Tavern (who have mostly been approved, I believe).

Just don't ask me. I'm already busy starting my other game.